In a column for Deadline, Oscar and Pulitzer winner John Patrick Shanley discusses his new Off Broadway play Mountain Girl, Hollywood industry upheaval, and why he opposed recent WGA strikes.
The NylonFusion Theatre Company and Axial Theatre production recently opened at 154 Theatre, with its run extended to November 28, Deadline reported. The play follows Connie, an aspiring writer dealing with a turbulent marriage, a complex relationship with her mother, and an artistic rivalry between spouses. Shanley explained that the work stems from an early interest in two writers—one who cannot start and one who cannot finish.
The Skim-Reader Takeaways
- Mountain Girl examines the artistic torment of writing through characters trapped in a creative standoff, running at 154 Theatre until November 28.
- Shanley stated he was deeply opposed to recent Writers Guild of America strikes, arguing they fought battles already lost and put careers on a multi-year hiatus.
- The playwright drew a stark contrast between European press engagement with the arts and domestic entertainment journalism.
The Genesis of Mountain Girl
Shanley detailed the long development of the play in conversation with Deadline New York Business Editor Dade Hayes. The project featured work-in-progress presentations in Los Angeles in 2022 followed by a five-day workshop in Paris in 2025.
“I was initially interested in two writers – one can’t start and one can’t finish,” Shanley told Deadline. He added that the narrative explores how people model behavior to manipulate partners into changing rather than enacting change directly.
The manuscript functions as a central focal point on stage. Shanley said that the struggles of creation matter far more than the final product. “Is the struggle noble? Is the struggle worthy?” he asked.
Contrasting Global Press Cultures
Reflecting on international productions, including an upcoming French-language version of Mountain Girl and a West End revival of Four Dogs and a Bone in London, Shanley contrasted foreign journalism with American media. He recalled a 1983 press trip to Spain for Danny and the Deep Blue Sea where interviewers compared his work to Dante.
“The American thing was, ‘What’s Cher like?!’ How much did the movie cost to make?'” Shanley told Deadline. He contrasted it with a later junket for the 1995 film Congo, where an interviewer asked about adapting Michael Crichton with immense solemnity, prompting him to reply, “Well, we’re not talking about Thomas Hardy.”
Addressing Cultural Shifts and AI in Hollywood
Addressing the broader turbulence in Hollywood, Shanley pointed to rapid cultural shifts, artificial intelligence, and corporate consolidation. He argued that filmmakers who invest heavily in expensive technology often leave behind the personal grounding necessary for sustainable art.
“They’ve left behind the bedrock that they can depend on, and to ground themselves as individual human beings and have a relationship with the sun coming up in the morning and the moon coming up in the evening, in favor of this artificial environment,” Shanley told Deadline.
On the topic of labor unrest, Shanley expressed strong reservations regarding union strikes. “I was deeply opposed to [the strikes], but I did not speak to the media about it because I felt that that would be undercutting,” Shanley told Deadline, adding that he believed the union fought lost battles that resulted in a damaging five-year hiatus for working professionals.
| Project | Role | Medium |
|---|---|---|
| Mountain Girl | Playwright | Off Broadway (154 Theatre) |
| Moonstruck | Screenwriter | Feature Film |
| Doubt | Playwright / Director | Broadway / Film |
| Four Dogs and a Bone | Playwright | West End Revival (London) |
Reflections on Studio Struggles
Shanley also addressed the initial hostile reception to his 1990 directorial effort Joe Versus the Volcano, starring Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan. He recalled constant friction with Warner Brothers during the 80-day shoot.
“New York press in particular was savage towards it,” Shanley told Deadline, noting that the harsh reception caused him to experience emotional burnout before regaining his creative confidence.