A Lang Son provincial court has vacated a commercial judgment involving a 25.05 billion VND debt default, stalling a bank’s attempt to foreclose on four mortgaged land parcels.
The appellate ruling, issued September 18, 2026, mandates a retrial to resolve ownership disputes regarding land currently occupied by a third party.
Between September 2022 and February 2023, the bank disbursed 18 billion VND to Dao Thuy H. across five credit agreements. By May 27, 2026, the liability reached 25.05 billion VND, comprising 17.6 billion VND in principal, 5.5 billion VND in accrued interest, and 1.8 billion VND in late-payment penalties, according to records from the Provincial People’s Court of Lang Son.
- Total Debt Escalation: The borrower’s obligation grew beyond the original 18 billion VND principal due to interest accumulation and default penalties.
- Collateral Impairment: The bank’s claim on land parcels 67 and 145 is contested by a third party, K., who currently operates a construction materials facility on the disputed acreage.
- Procedural Reset: The appellate court canceled the May 28, 2026, first-instance decision, requiring a new trial to address K.’s independent petition regarding land ownership.
The mortgage contract, signed January 11, 2019, and notarized on January 14, 2019, utilized land rights held by Le Hong S. and Tran Thi Y. as security. However, the legal validity of this collateral is now under scrutiny.
During site inspections, the court confirmed that 64.9 square meters of plot 67 and 5.9 square meters of plot 145 are managed by K., who claims to have utilized the area as part of a 5,000-square-meter site for C Construction Materials since 2008 without prior notice of the bank’s lien.
“I was unaware that the land I occupied was subject to a land-use certificate held by S. and Y.,” K. stated during proceedings. Consequently, the court found the original mortgage contract partially invalid, a decision the bank challenged in its appeal.
The borrower, Dao Thuy H., admitted to signing the loan agreements but testified that the funds were borrowed on behalf of Le Hong S. She said that the default was due to the business losses and death of Le Hong S. in 2023. Tran Thi Y., the widow of S., has requested a one-year extension on the loan term to facilitate repayment, citing the family’s business losses.
| Debt Component | Amount (VND) |
|---|---|
| Principal Balance | 17.6 Billion |
| Accrued Interest | 5.5 Billion |
| Late Payment Interest | 1.8 Billion |
| Total Indebtedness | 25.05 Billion |
The appellate court’s decision to annul the first-instance judgment effectively suspends the bank’s foreclosure timeline. While the initial ruling provided a deadline of May 28, 2027, for the borrower to satisfy the debt before the bank could initiate an auction, the retrial order forces a reopening of evidence collection.
The court said that K.’s independent petition is inextricably linked to the bank’s appeal, necessitating a comprehensive review to protect the rights of all stakeholders, including the third-party occupant.
As the case returns to the lower court, the bank remains unable to liquidate the collateral. The final resolution will hinge on the court’s determination of the mortgage’s validity regarding the disputed 70.8 square meters, which remains the primary barrier to debt recovery.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.