LYR Value Fund Beats Peers in 2025 After Category Shift

The fund has quietly outperformed most of its value-fund peers in 2025, gaining 17.84% through the year’s final stretch versus 10.24% for its category average, according to Morningstar data.

The fund, which hunts for mid- and large-cap U.S. stocks trading below their long-term normalized earnings, sits in the top quartile of its category for the year.

That headline number, though, comes with a wrinkle that matters to anyone tracking the fund: the fund spent the last five years bumping between categories. Morningstar moved the fund from its Large Value grouping into Mid-Cap Value in 2021, and the performance record now reads across both peer sets — a detail that changes how the streak should be judged.

The fund beats its category average in 2025

  • The fund is up 17.84% in 2025 through the latest data, beating its Mid-Cap Value category average of 10.24% and ranking in the top quartile.
  • The fund’s long-term record is uneven: a 10-year annualized return of 11.04% trails its index benchmark’s 15.33%.
  • Morningstar reclassified the fund from Large Value to Mid-Cap Value in 2021, so its percentile rankings before and after sit against different peer groups.

The fund shows inconsistent returns

The same fund that ranks first in its category this year ranked fourth — the bottom rung — as recently as 2022, when it lost 17.44% while its category average fell just 8.02%, per Morningstar's annual return table. Value investing is a streaky business, and the fund’s decade tells that story.

The fund beat its index in 2016 (14.59% versus 11.96%), then ran off three strong years, including a first-quartile 2017 where its 21.32% gain topped both the category’s 13.22% and the index’s 21.83%. Then came 2018, when its 19.75% loss against a category decline of 12.86% landed it in the fourth quartile with a percentile rank of 100 — dead last among 417 funds.

But the math tells a different story over the longer arc. Across three-, five- and ten-year windows, the fund’s annualized returns of 19.83%, 11.28% and 11.04% all beat their category averages of 14.79%, 9.01% and 9.75%, Morningstar’s trailing-return table shows. Against the index, however, the fund trails at every one of those horizons — 19.83% versus 22.89% over three years, 11.28% versus 13.79% over five, 11.04% versus 15.33% over ten.

Value strategies surface entertainment conglomerates

A mid- and large-cap value fund is not an entertainment story on its face — but the two worlds keep colliding. The strategy the fund pursues, buying diversified portfolios of U.S.-listed common stocks at low valuations relative to normalized earnings, is precisely the screen that tends to surface legacy media and entertainment conglomerates: businesses with real cash flows, mature franchises and price tags the market has marked down.

When value rotates back into favor, as it has in stretches of 2025, media-heavy pockets of the market are often along for the ride.

That matters for readers who follow the streaming wars and studio earnings cycles, because the same valuation logic that drives a value fund’s portfolio also drives how Wall Street prices entertainment assets.

A studio stock trading below normalized earnings is exactly the kind of holding a fund like this would consider — and when hundreds of value managers reach the same conclusion at once, the re-rating shows up in the sector’s stock prices long before it shows up on a balance sheet.

The fund’s mandate, as Morningstar’s summary states, is to invest principally in a diversified portfolio of common stock of mid-capitalization and large-capitalization companies with low valuations relative to their long-term normalized earnings, with at least 80% of net assets plus borrowings in U.S.-exchange-traded stocks. Long-term capital growth is the stated goal.

The decade, year by year

Morningstar’s annual table runs from 2016 through 2025, and it tracks the fund, its category and its index side by side — along with the category switch in 2021. The numbers below are the fund’s calendar-year total returns against its peer group average:

Year Fund return Category return Quartile Category
2016 14.59% 18.06% Second Large Value
2017 21.32% 13.22% First Large Value
2018 -19.75% -12.86% Fourth Large Value
2019 23.54% 25.18% Third Large Value
2020 8.63% 2.63% First Large Value
2021 30.11% 29.32% Second Mid-Cap Value
2022 -17.44% -8.02% Fourth Mid-Cap Value
2023 27.62% 13.94% First Mid-Cap Value
2024 13.00% 11.43% Second Mid-Cap Value
2025 17.84% 17.79% Fourth Mid-Cap Value

Look at the pattern and a rhythm emerges. The fund’s best relative years — 2017, 2020, 2023 — came when it beat its category. Its worst, 2018 and 2022, came in broad drawdowns. Value funds that concentrate their bets tend to live on this seesaw.

Recent performance shows month-to-month softness

The short-term picture is messier than the annual table suggests. Over the trailing one-month window, the fund returned -3.39% against a category decline of -5.73%. Over three months, it slipped 1.40% while the category fell 1.75%. Year-to-date on the trailing table, the fund shows 12.47%, alongside a one-year figure of 14.68%.

What both tables agree on is the shape of the story: strong 2025 relative performance, recent month-to-month softness, and a long-term record that beats peers but not the index.

What the peer counts reveal

One more number deserves attention. The number of funds in the fund’s Morningstar category has drifted from 399 in 2016 to 383 in the latest year-to-date count, peaking above 420 in the late 2010s. A shrinking peer pool means the competitive field for value investors has consolidated — a quiet structural shift in the ETF and mutual fund business that makes every quartile ranking a moving target.

Percentile ranks tell the same story with sharper edges. A percentile rank of 4 in 2023 means the fund beat nearly all of its Mid-Cap Value peers that year. A rank of 98 in 2022 means it beat almost none of them. Twelve months separated those two results.

Where this leaves the fund

For investors who hold the fund, the takeaway from the data is straightforward: 2025 has been a year of performance, the trailing three- and five-year records beat the category, and the ten-year record trails the index by more than four percentage points annually.

For entertainment-industry watchers, the deeper signal is what a strong year for mid-cap value says about where capital is flowing — toward reasonably priced, cash-generative companies and away from the growth premium that defined the last decade.

The fund’s own category journey — from Large Value to Mid-Cap Value in 2021, per Morningstar’s classification history — is the final piece of context.

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Westerly Woman Runs Crochet Business by Touch After Vision Loss

Homeland Security Chief Floats Theory AI “Super Intelligence” Caused US Tech Outages