A randomized controlled trial conducted at the Kalinga Institute of Medical Sciences evaluated the efficacy of microneedling versus fractional carbon dioxide laser, both paired with platelet-rich plasma, for treating atrophic acne scars. While both methods significantly reduced scarring, laser-based treatment provided superior qualitative improvements despite increased post-procedural inflammation and recovery time.
Clinical Utility of Scar Resurfacing Combinations
Atrophic acne scarring remains a significant clinical challenge, affecting approximately 14% of individuals who experience acne vulgaris. To address this, clinicians often employ resurfacing techniques designed to stimulate dermal remodeling. A recent study, published in Cureus, provides a head-to-head comparison of two common approaches: microneedling (MN) and fractional carbon dioxide laser (FCL), both augmented with topical platelet-rich plasma (PRP).
The trial, which spanned from March 2024 to March 2026, enrolled 52 participants, with 48 completing the full three-session protocol. Researchers categorized participants into two groups: Group A received MN with topical PRP, while Group B received FCL with topical PRP. Both groups demonstrated a statistically significant reduction in quantitative scar scores, indicating that both modalities successfully trigger the body’s natural repair cascade.
Both Treatments Cut Scar Depth; Laser Patients Report Better Satisfaction
- Similar Objective Results: Both microneedling and fractional CO2 laser treatments significantly improve acne scars when combined with PRP, with no major difference in the overall reduction of scar depth.
- Quality of Life and Appearance: Patients treated with the fractional CO2 laser reported higher satisfaction and greater improvement in how their skin looked and felt compared to those treated with microneedling.
- Recovery Trade-offs: Microneedling is generally better tolerated with less downtime, whereas the laser treatment results in more intense, though temporary, redness, swelling, and discomfort after the procedure.
Comparative Outcomes of Resurfacing Modalities
While quantitative measurements—which track the physical depth and number of scars—showed similar efficacy between the two groups, qualitative outcomes diverged. The study reported that 39.1% of patients in the laser-treated group (Group B) achieved “macular-grade” scarring—the mildest form of scar—compared to only 16.0% in the microneedling group (Group A).
These results suggest that while both methods are effective, the fractional CO2 laser may offer a more profound aesthetic shift for certain patients.
Patient-reported measures, including the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and the Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI), favored the laser-based approach. The intense thermal energy delivered by the fractional CO2 laser, which induces controlled photothermolysis, appears to provide a stronger stimulus for collagen reorganization than the mechanical injury caused by microneedling. However, this intensity comes with a cost in the form of increased erythema (redness) and edema (swelling) observed 72 hours post-treatment.
Founded in 2007 as a constituent school of medicine under the KIIT Deemed-to-be-University, the Kalinga Institute of Medical Sciences has grown to become the largest healthcare service provider in Eastern India. The institution has gained national recognition for its academic and clinical standing, having been ranked among the top private medical institutes in India by multiple national surveys.
| Outcome Metric | Group A (MN + PRP) | Group B (FCL + PRP) |
|---|---|---|
| Median Scar Reduction | 33.33% | 35.29% |
| Macular-Grade Achievement | 16.0% | 39.1% |
| Post-Treatment Inflammation | Lower | Higher |
Research Transparency and Institutional Oversight
The study adhered to the Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) guidelines to ensure reliable data integrity. The research was approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee (KIIT/KIMS/IEC/1563/2024), ensuring that all patient data and procedures met established ethical standards for clinical research.
References
- Kar BR, et al. A comparative study evaluated the efficacy and safety of microneedling versus fractional CO2 laser, both paired with topical PRP, for the treatment of atrophic acne scars. Cureus. 2026.