White-collar hiring typically falls in November and December, which makes the final weeks of the year the wrong window for applying to jobs but a strong window for networking — and the difference between a productive cold email and a deleted one comes down to specificity, subject lines, and dropping phrases like “Can I pick your brain?”
MarketWatch reported that the last five years of Bureau of Labor Statistics data show hiring for white-collar roles dips during the final months of the year, meaning job seekers are unlikely to land a position before the year ends — through no fault of their own skills or personality.
The flip side: attention spent on what career watchers call “doomjobbing” — scrolling LinkedIn and Indeed with no result — is better redirected toward cold emails to former colleagues, old bosses, or outright strangers. By the BLS’s own figures, cited by MarketWatch, roughly 70% of jobs are found through networking.
For the hesitant, there is survey-backed comfort. A 2022 study published by the American Psychological Association found that people significantly underestimate how much recipients appreciate out-of-the-blue emails — and the more surprised a person is by an email, the more they tend to value it.
Use hiring lull for outreach
- November and December are historically the worst hiring months for white-collar roles, per BLS data analyzed by MarketWatch — so use the lull for outreach, not applications.
- Vague asks (“quick question,” “pick your brain,” “let’s grab coffee”) suppress response rates; bounded, specific requests such as a 20-minute phone call make it easy to say yes.
- About 47% of workers use AI to write emails, per 2026 data from Omni Calculator, so a visibly human, imperfect message stands out.
Why ‘quick question’ gets ignored
Claire Wasserman, a career coach and author of “Ladies Get Paid,” told MarketWatch that vague openers signal the opposite of urgency. Her rule for subject lines: name the mutual connection — a school, company, field or friend — and state what you want. “Say who you are, or why them — never ‘quick question,’ ‘job inquiry’ or ‘opportunity,'” Wasserman said.

Keep the subject line under six words so it isn’t cut off on a phone, and make sure it matches the message. Some examples include “Fellow former teacher looking for advice” and “Dana Lee suggested I reach out.”
Then comes the phrase she flags as the most annoying in the genre: “I’d love to pick your brain.” “‘Picking your brain’ is too abstract,” she explained. “People make it way too open-ended. It’s like, ‘I’m way too busy to deal with this.'”
Buy time, not coffee
“People are much more likely to respond when you aren’t asking for their time in a vague, open-ended way, but rather asking for their expertise on a specific challenge you’re solving,” Joy said.
Wasserman’s version: put a number on the ask. “Say, ‘Hey, are you free for a 20-minute phone call?'” she suggested. “Don’t make it so hard for the person to say yes.”
Do the research the internet already did
Preparation is the other filter. billionaire Mark Cuban, whom MarketWatch cold-emailed for the story, replied that questions should reflect the sender’s homework. “You need to get their respect by making the questions you ask a reflection of your preparation,” Cuban told MarketWatch in a message after we cold-emailed him. “Nothing turns me off more than being asked a question I’ve answered online or elsewhere 25 times.”
The same standard applies to hiring managers at nonfamous companies: don’t ask about a role or employer when the answer is a search away. Tessa West, a psychology professor at New York University and author of “Jerks at Work,” adds a warning on the other flank — flattery.
Don’t tell recipients how great they are; the email itself proves you respect them, and what they want to know is why you’re contacting them specifically. Her suggested framing: “I noticed that you worked at KPMG for three years,” or pointing to a role-to-role transition you want to replicate.
West also flagged name-dropping popular figures as counterproductive. “It looks thirsty and desperate,” she said. “Just be honest about how you heard about them — and a close friend or colleague is better than some influencer anyway.”
Imperfect emails stand out
The data on polish is this: 2026 data from Omni Calculator, cited by MarketWatch, puts AI-assisted email writing at 47% of workers. Workplace-performance expert Henna Pryor argues that slightly imperfect, openly human messages now outperform flawless ones — and may even read as AI-written when they’re too smooth.
“Naming the discomfort shrinks it for both people, and it gives the other person permission to be human back,” Pryor said. “When AI can make every message sound perfect, a little visible awkwardness is proof a real person wrote it.”
Out of touch for three years? Fine
Alison Green, founder of the Ask A Manager column, told MarketWatch the guilt about long silences is misplaced. “It’s perfectly fine to reach out after a long time has gone by,” she said. “With professional networking, it’s not rude to pop up again after a long period of time has gone by.”
Jennifer Wallace, author of “Mattering: The Secret to a Life of Deep Connection And Purpose,” extends the playbook past the first reply: close the loop by reporting what happened with someone’s advice weeks later. When advice visibly mattered, she noted, people “feel invested in your success and are more willing to want to help again” — which matters most for remote workers who rarely see their contacts in person.
The seasonal math, in one table
| Metric | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Share of jobs found through networking | 70% | Bureau of Labor Statistics, cited by MarketWatch |
| Workers using AI to write emails (2026) | 47% | Omni Calculator, cited by MarketWatch |
| Suggested cold-email call length | 20 minutes | Claire Wasserman |
With hiring data pointing to a slow quarter and a low-hire, low-fire labor market hitting new graduates hardest, the tactical takeaway from the practitioners quoted here is uniform: specific asks, bounded time, visible humanity. Put differently, in Wasserman’s phrasing: “Don’t make it so hard for the person to say yes.”