Philosophers Debate Why Virtual Murder Is Accepted but Sexual Assault Is Not in Games

Virtual murder in Grand Theft Auto is widely considered ethically acceptable by players, while simulated sexual assault or torture remains off-limits. Charles Sturt University Associate Professor Morgan Luck formulated the gamer’s dilemma to address this puzzle, noting that virtual wrongdoings are not real, yet philosophers still struggle to morally differentiate between these acts.

The Gamer Dilemma

Most gamers will tell you that intentionally driving over an innocent pedestrian in Grand Theft Auto, and killing them, is ethically OK, The Conversation reported. Virtual wrongdoings are not real. They are just part of a game. While research connects violent video games to aggressive thoughts, little research links virtual wrongdoings to increased real-world counterparts.

Murdering people in a game doesn’t make you more likely to murder in real life.

The problem is that all virtual wrongdoings share this fictional status. Nobody is really murdered in GTA, but nobody is actually sexually assaulted in the modded version either. Yet many argue those latter acts are unacceptable. Gamers face the challenge of morally differentiating off-limits virtual actions from fair-game virtual actions.

Competing Philosophical Theories

Philosophers have tried to solve this dilemma by identifying moral differences. Philosopher and University of Iowa professor Stephanie Patridge argues some virtual acts are wrong because of the incorrigible social meaning they carry. This explains why murdering sex workers in GTA is wrong: such media representations cast women as objects of sexual pleasure and violence.

Other scholars focus on context rather than the act itself. Santa Clara University professor Eric Ramirez argues a virtual wrongdoing becomes morally salient when it is so realistic that it is experienced as if it were real.

Empirical research supports this concern over realism. A virtual reality murder simulator is seen as ethically distinct from virtual murder on an arcade machine.

A third approach resists the underlying moral foundations of the gamer’s dilemma altogether.

Macquarie University professor Paul Formosa and another researcher have argued that these intuitions might be guided by conventional norms specific to video games and their history. We might not endorse virtual murder so readily without the widespread acceptance of killing bad guys in shooter games.

Leonida Roads

While philosophers have offered several promising approaches, no single approach has proven successful. Philosophers do not claim the ethics of video games should mirror real life. That would be overly moralistic.

The puzzle reminds us that the virtuality of our conduct cannot always excuse it. Gamers are left in a dubious position on the roads of Leonida.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Peter Fluck, Spitting Image Co-Creator, Dies at 85

Lebanese Villagers Returned in July to Destroyed Homes Under U.S. Ceasefire Plan