A Romanian lawyer can no longer appear before the European Court of Human Rights for two years, barred on Friday over AI-drafted submissions that cited cases which never existed.
The decision, taken on November 13 and announced in a media release on Thursday, The Irish Times reported, followed findings that her written observations contained “a pattern of numerous, repeated substantive errors rather than isolated citation mistakes.” The court’s president, Mattias Guyomar, approved the exclusion after a chamber of the court proposed it.
The lawyer, whom the court’s account of the two-year exclusion does not name, had used artificial intelligence tools to draft observations in a case where she acted as one of two representatives for the applicant. She acknowledged that. She described the mistakes as “inaccuracies” and “citation errors.”
The chamber saw something structural, not clerical. The filings cited nonexistent, “hallucinated” cases. They invented paragraphs inside judgments that were real. And they leaned on existing case law that was either irrelevant to the arguments being advanced or plainly contradicted the submissions it was meant to support.
Romanian lawyer barred for two years from representing applicants before the European Court of Human Rights over unverified AI generated citations. 🔗 https://t.co/ekPUPFZ0hK
Exclusion from practice is reserved for what the court’s rules call “exceptional circumstances,” and the chamber found the threshold met. The reason reaches past one lawyer’s caseload: the errors forced the court itself to spend considerable time verifying the observations, to open proceedings under its rules and to correspond extensively with other stakeholders.
Citations That Never Existed
The findings read like an audit of what happens when drafting is delegated and verification is skipped. Nonexistent cases. Fictitious paragraphs inside genuine judgments. Real case law deployed against the very propositions it was cited to prove.
The lawyer’s framing suggested slips of the pen. The chamber’s framing suggested a habit: repeated, substantive errors across the submissions, not a stray citation here or there. That distinction drove the outcome.
There was a cost, too, and the chamber named who paid it. The lawyer’s conduct caused prejudice to the administration of justice, The Irish Times reported, because the court had to divert its resources to checking the filings, running disciplinary proceedings and corresponding with stakeholders — work it considered incompatible with its real functions under the European Convention on Human Rights.
That phrase carries the weight of the decision. The Strasbourg court exists to judge whether states have breached their human rights obligations. Verifying whether a case exists is not among its functions, and the chamber treated the time spent on it as a loss to the system itself.
The Check That Never Happened
The chamber grounded the exclusion in duties the lawyer already owed, independent of any new technology. Under the Legal Profession Act, the rules governing the legal profession and the court’s case law, advocates must act as “reasonably competent” professionals and display a high level of professional prudence before the court, The Irish Times reported.
In this case, the chamber said, that duty meant one concrete step: independently and carefully checking every case-law reference and argument the AI tools generated against authoritative sources — the court’s own case-law database chief among them — before submitting anything.
The lawyer admitted she had not sufficiently checked all the case law she cited. The chamber called that an “understatement.” For certain references, it found, no checks were carried out at all, and many of the errors were repetitive enough to surface in a “cursory” check of the database.
The process was not summary. The chamber invited comments from the lawyer, the Romanian government and the Romanian National Bar Association, and took those responses into account before sending Guyomar its reasoned proposal for a two-year exclusion.
Scope matters here as well. The president’s decision bars her from representing or otherwise assisting litigants before the court — the full reach of the rules, which allow the exclusion of an advocate or other persons from acting for a party. The court’s own release framed the grounds plainly: unverified AI-generated citations.
Restoration Remains Possible
The ban runs two years from the November 13 decision, and it stops at the lawyer’s own conduct. The applicant’s second representative is unaffected, and the chamber’s decision leaves that advocate free to keep acting in the case.
The European Court of Human Rights, based in Strasbourg, France, was established on 21 January 1959 under the European Convention on Human Rights and decided its first case, Lawless v. Ireland, in 1960. Individuals, groups of individuals or contracting states may lodge applications alleging that a state has breached rights under the Convention, and all 46 member states of the Council of Europe recognise its jurisdiction.
Scholars consider it the most effective international human rights court in the world, and its caseload grew sharply after the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989, when accession of new states brought a surge of applications.
It is not framed as permanent, either. The court was explicit on that point: the decision “does not prejudice the possibility of the lawyer having her rights of representation restored.”