Following the weekend fixture, Manchester United’s interim head coach Michael Carrick has been advised by senior club figures to pursue the re-signing of £72m summer acquisition Antony, a move met with surprise by former left-back Patrice Evra given the winger’s underwhelming adaptation to the Premier League’s physical demands and tactical rigidity under previous regimes. The directive signals a potential shift in United’s transfer strategy, prioritizing familiarity and perceived upside over new acquisitions as the club navigates Financial Fair Play constraints ahead of the summer window.
Fantasy & Market Impact
Antony’s potential return could elevate his fantasy value as a differential winger option, particularly if deployed in a liberated role under Carrick’s preference for fluid attacking transitions.
Antony’s £72m valuation complicates United’s FFP calculations; re-signing would likely necessitate player sales or loan deals to avoid breaching UEFA’s profitability and sustainability rules.
Antony’s inconsistent output (0.38 xG per 90 in 2025/26) presents a risk-reward dilemma for fantasy managers, with upside tied to improved shot creation in a system emphasizing wide overloads.
Antony’s Tactical Misfit and the Carrick Contradiction
Antony’s arrival in summer 2024 was predicated on his ability to replicate the inverted winger role that flourished under Erik ten Hag at Ajax, yet his 2025/26 season has been marked by a 38% success rate in one-on-one duels and a tendency to drift into congested central zones, disrupting United’s midfield rhythm. Under Carrick’s interim tenure, the Dutchman has advocated for a 4-2-3-1 structure that relies on wingers providing width and stretching play — a demand antithetical to Antony’s natural inclination to cut inside and operate in half-spaces. This tactical misalignment has resulted in Antony averaging just 2.1 progressive carries per 90 minutes, the lowest among United’s primary wide attackers.
Antony United CarrickAntony United Carrick
Carrick’s reported directive to re-sign Antony appears counterintuitive given these metrics, but sources indicate the former midfielder believes the player’s struggles stem from inconsistent coaching messages and a lack of defined role clarity rather than inherent inability. Carrick’s preference for a possession-based, progression-oriented system may actually suit Antony if deployed as a traditional right-winger in a 4-3-3, allowing him to exploit space behind opposing fullbacks without the burden of creating in tight areas.
Financial Implications and FFP Tightrope
Re-signing Antony would not involve a new transfer fee but would reactivate his existing five-year contract signed in July 2024, which carries an annual amortization cost of £14.4m and a reported gross salary of £180,000 per week. With United currently projecting a £25m FFP deficit for the 2025/26 season under UEFA’s updated sustainability framework, reintegrating Antony would exacerbate short-term pressures unless offset by player departures. The club’s wage bill, already among the highest in the Premier League at £380m annually, would see minimal reduction if Antony remains, complicating efforts to comply with the 70% revenue threshold for squad costs.
Give Carrick the Man Utd Job ft Ryan Giggs & Evra | How Cole Palmer Signing Would Help Bruno
Conversely, selling Antony now would yield limited returns given his depreciated market value — estimated at £45m by the CIES Football Observatory — potentially triggering a book loss that further impacts FFP compliance. This financial bind explains why internal voices favor retention and rehabilitation over immediate sale, despite sporting reservations.
Evra’s Surprise and the Legacy Lens
“I never thought I’d see the day when United would consider doubling down on a player who’s looked so lost in our system. Antony needs time, yes, but at £72m, You can’t afford to wait for a breakthrough that may never come.”
Antony United Carrick
Evra’s critique reflects a broader concern among United’s old guard that the club is prioritizing emotional familiarity over objective performance metrics. However, Carrick’s camp counters that Antony’s underlying numbers — particularly his 0.45 xA per 90 and 82% pass completion in the final third — suggest untapped creative potential if placed in a system that minimizes defensive transitions and maximizes his technical strengths in tight spaces.
Historically, United have shown patience with high-cost wingers; Angel di María struggled similarly in 2014/15 before finding form under Louis van Gaal’s adjusted system. Whether Antony can undergo a similar evolution remains uncertain, but Carrick’s willingness to revisit the investment suggests a belief in long-term project continuity over short-term expediency.
The Path Forward: Integration or Exit?
United’s next steps will hinge on Antony’s preseason performance and Carrick’s ability to secure a permanent managerial role. If retained, the club may look to offload redundant wide players — such as Jadon Sancho or Facundo Pellistri — to create salary cap space and reinforce tactical clarity. Alternatively, a summer sale could generate funds to pursue a more traditional wide attacker, potentially targeting players like Real Sociedad’s Takefusa Kubo or Benfica’s João Neves, whose profiles better align with United’s stated need for width and goal threat.
the Antony saga encapsulates United’s broader identity crisis: balancing fiscal responsibility with sporting ambition, and reconciling past investments with evolving tactical realities. Until a coherent vision emerges from the boardroom to the training ground, decisions like this will continue to be viewed through a lens of skepticism — even as they carry significant implications for the club’s short-term competitiveness and long-term financial health.
*Disclaimer: The fantasy and market insights provided are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute financial or betting advice.*
Senior Editor, Sport
Luis is a respected sports journalist with several national writing awards. He covers major leagues, global tournaments, and athlete profiles, blending analysis with captivating storytelling.
