An orca named Tahlequah spent at least 17 days in 2018 swimming with the body of her dead calf.
Scientists are still weighing what such behavior means, according to a New York Times analysis on grief in animals.
Whether animals grieve remains an open question. Grief is a complex, often long-lasting psychological and biological response to loss. For decades, many scientists considered mourning an exclusively human trait, and researchers who argued otherwise were often accused of the sin of anthropomorphism, attributing human emotions to animals without adequate data.
And at the same time, a challenge for scientists.
Deaths among animals are often unpredictable and invisible, especially in the wild. Mourning is a heavy concept: it is easy to project human experience onto other creatures and impossible to truly enter their minds. Still, the field is moving. “The field is now ripe for growth,” said Andre Goncalves, a scientist at the Indianapolis Zoological Society.
The @nytimes asks, "Do Animals Grieve?" Of course they do. While I'm glad to see ink spilled over the emotions of animals, sometimes I scratch my head at the obsession over trying to scientifically prove something that is SO self-evident. https://t.co/DTrVEUT7xs
A turning point came in 2008. An elderly chimpanzee named Pansy died and, unintentionally, gave scientists new evidence. The next morning, keepers removed pieces of straw from her body while other chimpanzees watched in silence.
In 2010, Anderson and his colleagues published a detailed analysis of the case. They said that the chimpanzees' behavior was strikingly similar to human reactions to a peaceful death, and argued that chimpanzees' awareness of death had likely been underestimated. The Pansy case helped open a new field of research.
Even behaviors that look like clear grief can have other explanations. In a 2021 meta-analysis, Carter and colleagues found that primate mothers were more likely to carry dead infants when the deaths came from non-traumatic causes such as illness, rather than accidents or attacks that left visible wounds. The behavior was also more common among younger mothers.
One possible explanation: some mothers keep carrying their infant because they have not fully registered that it is dead.
Coyotes, at least, are not the loners their reputation suggests. According to the New York Times analysis, they are “deeply” faithful to their mates: they stay together for life, groom each other, share food and raise their young together.
The public is far more willing to accept animal grief than researchers are. In a survey of 1,000 adults in Australia, 90% answered that at least some animals can experience grief, and 23% believed all animals have that capacity.
Among those who believed animals can mourn, 18% attributed the ability even to ants, and 10% to shrimp.
You can't just say that animals grieve and then not support it with data. Even so, she sees many reasons now to believe animals can experience grief — and as more scientific data accumulate, she prefers to leave open the possibility that their sadness is real.