First-time mothers showed significant declines in parenting self-confidence, coping capacity, and self-responsibility after childbirth, research finds, even though their depression screening scores stayed flat.
The prospective cohort study, published in BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth, tracked women from early pregnancy through one month postpartum.
The gap is the point.
A mother can love her baby deeply, feel her self-esteem rise, and still lose confidence in her own ability to cope — and none of that shows up on a depression checklist.
What the Japanese cohort actually measured
The research team, led by Sakaaki Machimura with Shoko Sugao, Makoto Fujii and colleagues, ran an open prospective cohort study — meaning participants were enrolled ahead of time and followed forward, though without a comparison group or blinding. Pregnant women aged 20 or older registered through a web-based platform between January 2020 and May 2024.
Each participant completed assessments at six intervals: early, mid, and late pregnancy, during the delivery hospitalization, and again at two-week and one-month postpartum check-ups. Two instruments did the work. The Comprehensive Scale for Parenting Resilience and Adaptation measured five resilience domains; the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale tracked depressive symptoms.

Retention was the study’s central limitation. Of 1,474 women initially registered, 220 completed every assessment through one month postpartum — about 15 percent of the starting cohort. The retained sample split into 120 first-time mothers (primiparous) and 100 mothers with prior delivery experience (multiparous).
| Measure | Cohort total | First-time mothers | Experienced mothers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initially registered | 1,474 | — | — |
| Completed all six assessments | 220 | 120 | 100 |
First-time mothers show steeper confidence declines
The researchers used generalized linear mixed modeling — a statistical method that handles repeated measurements from the same person over time — to analyze trajectories across the five resilience domains in relation to delivery and parity.
What emerged were domain-specific trajectories, not one uniform story. Self-confidence declined, and so did perceived possibility of coping and self-responsibility, with first-time mothers showing significantly steeper drops than experienced mothers. The study framed this as a distinct vulnerability among women caring for infants without prior experience.
At the same time, emotional and relational metrics moved the other way. Scores for love for the child and overall self-esteem improved significantly after childbirth in both parity groups. The depression scale told no story at all: Edinburgh scores showed no statistically significant change across pregnancy and postpartum, and no difference between first-time and experienced mothers.
New mothers' confidence drops while love for baby rises
- A new mother can be struggling with confidence and coping while scoring completely normally on a depression screen — the two measure different things.
- First-time mothers bore the largest adaptation declines in this study; experienced mothers declined less on the same measures.
- Love for the baby and self-esteem improved after birth in both groups — declining confidence is not the same as failing to bond.
Why the Edinburgh scale missed it
The Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale asks about depressive symptoms — mood, anxiety, thoughts of self-harm — not about parental self-efficacy, which is the psychological term for a parent’s belief in her own capability. A woman can answer every depression item favorably while her sense of coping competence collapses. The study authors concluded that adaptation involves distinct, domain-specific trajectories that depressive symptom screening does not detect.
Earlier research had examined single variables such as parental self-efficacy in isolation. What remained scarce, the authors write, was a comprehensive analysis tracking multidimensional adaptation across both pregnancy and the postpartum period — the gap this cohort was designed to fill.
What the study cannot yet tell us
The authors themselves flag the open questions. The Comprehensive Scale for Parenting Resilience and Adaptation offers a broader evaluative framework, but further longitudinal and interventional research is necessary before it can direct postpartum support in clinics. No health regulator — not the FDA, EMA, or any national screening body — currently mandates a resilience-domain assessment alongside depression screening, and this single-cohort study does not change that.
Attribution limits apply here too. The source reports do not state the study’s funding source, so no funding disclosure can be confirmed from the available material. The web-based enrollment also means the sample may not represent women without internet access or those who dropped out — 1,254 registrants did not complete all six time points.
Mothers with persistent confidence loss should contact providers
This is observational research, not a treatment, so there is nothing to avoid or take. The relevant clinical action is the one the findings imply: any mother — particularly a first-time mother — who experiences persistent loss of confidence, a sense she cannot cope, or mounting feelings of responsibility-related distress after delivery should raise this with her midwife, obstetrician, or family physician, since a standard depression screen may not capture it.
Postpartum depression remains a distinct, serious condition; the Edinburgh scale remains the validated tool for it, and worrying symptoms such as low mood, anxiety, or thoughts of self-harm always warrant prompt professional evaluation.
Where this goes next
The authors state plainly what follows: longitudinal and interventional studies must test whether measuring resilience domains actually improves postpartum support, not just documents it. Until then, the paper stands as a measurement problem made visible — 220 women whose depression scores barely moved while their confidence did.
References
- Machimura, S., Sugao, S., Fujii, M., Watanabe, H., Matsuzaki, M., Nakamoto, G., Takeda, T., Kitabatake, Y., Endo, M., and Kimura, T., publishing in 2026. Assessing perinatal resilience with the Comprehensive Scale for Parenting Resilience and Adaptation: how psychological adaptation to parenting shifts from before birth to afterward. BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth. BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth