The Importance of Backup Quarterbacks in the NFL
The Philadelphia Eagles have long prioritized their backup quarterback position, and for good reason. In fact, their success in winning the Super Bowl in 2017 can be attributed in large part to the performance of their backup quarterback, Nick Foles. But Foles is not the only backup quarterback who has stepped up for the Eagles over the years. Koy Detmer, A.J. Feeley, and Jeff Garcia have all played pivotal roles in keeping the team’s season alive when the starting quarterback was injured.
Given the vital importance of the backup quarterback position for the Eagles, it comes as no surprise that they recently acquired Kenny Pickett from the Pittsburgh Steelers. However, what is surprising is the trade that took place to acquire Pickett. The Eagles were reportedly trying to trade for Justin Fields but ended up settling for Pickett for a lesser draft compensation.
So, did the Eagles make the right move in acquiring Pickett, or should they have waited for Fields? There are some compelling reasons to support their decision. One such reason is the cost. The Eagles will have two seasons of Pickett compared to just one season of Fields. Additionally, Fields’ fifth-year option in 2025 would have come with a hefty price tag, which the Eagles would likely decline since they have already invested in Jalen Hurts as their franchise quarterback.
Another factor to consider is the cost of acquiring a backup quarterback. In the past, the Eagles have been able to secure backup quarterbacks like Gardner Minshew and Marcus Mariota at a relatively low cost. Pickett’s current contract also makes more financial sense for the Eagles when compared to Fields’. These considerations likely played a significant role in the Eagles’ decision-making process.
It is also worth noting that Eagles general manager Howie Roseman had his eye on Pickett for a while. Even when Hurts was the starting quarterback in 2021, Roseman was scouting Pickett and evaluating him throughout his senior season. Therefore, the Eagles have a backup quarterback who fits their offensive system and has been specifically chosen to complement Hurts’ playing style.
On the other hand, Fields might have had a better opportunity in Pittsburgh. With a one-year contract for starting quarterback Russell Wilson, Fields has a chance to prove himself and potentially become the Steelers’ long-term quarterback. This opportunity would not have been available to Fields in Philadelphia, where Hurts is firmly entrenched as the starter.
Analyzing the implications of the Eagles’ decision, it is clear that backup quarterbacks play a crucial role in the success of NFL teams. Injuries are an unfortunate reality in football, and having a capable backup quarterback can make all the difference in keeping a season alive. The Eagles’ focus on securing quality backup quarterbacks not only provides insurance but also allows them to develop players for future roles, as evident in their recent acquisitions.
Looking ahead, this trend of prioritizing backup quarterbacks is likely to continue in the NFL. Teams will invest in finding capable backups who can step in and perform at a high level when called upon. Quarterback competitions and opportunities for young players to shine will also become more prevalent, as teams seek to secure the long-term success of their franchise.
In conclusion, the Philadelphia Eagles’ decision to acquire Kenny Pickett as their backup quarterback speaks to the ongoing importance of this position in the NFL. The cost, financial considerations, and fit within the team’s system all played a role in the Eagles’ decision-making process. As the league evolves, it will be fascinating to see how other teams adapt and prioritize their backup quarterbacks.