Three California residents have been sentenced for their roles in an elaborate insurance fraud scheme that involved damaging luxury vehicles while wearing a bear costume, authorities confirmed.
The defendants were convicted of filing false claims after staging incidents where a person in a bear suit allegedly clawed and scratched high-end cars, including a Rolls-Royce and a Mercedes-Benz, to collect insurance payouts. Court records show the scam resulted in over $140,000 in fraudulent claims before investigators uncovered the ruse.
According to the San Bernardino County District Attorney’s Office, the trio conspired to defraud multiple insurance companies between 2020 and 2022 by reporting deliberate damage to their own vehicles, which they claimed was caused by a wild bear. Surveillance footage and forensic analysis later revealed the damage was inflicted using bear paws and claws attached to a costume, not by an actual animal.
Court Sentences Defendants in Bear-Suit Fraud Case
In April 2024, a San Bernardino County Superior Court judge sentenced the three defendants to probation, community service, and restitution after they pleaded no contest to felony insurance fraud charges. The primary defendant, identified as Ruben Tamrazian, received three years of formal probation, 30 days of community service, and was ordered to pay nearly $90,000 in restitution to the affected insurance companies.
His co-defendants, Ararat Chirakjian and Vahe Muradkhanyan, each received similar probation terms and were required to pay restitution amounting to approximately $25,000 and $30,000 respectively. All three were also mandated to complete anti-fraud education programs as part of their sentencing.
The case drew public attention due to its unusual method, with investigators noting the sophistication of the staged scenes, including fake bear tracks and strategically placed fur at the scenes to support the false narrative.
Investigation Uncovered Staged Damage Patterns
Insurance fraud investigators from the California Department of Insurance first became suspicious after noticing a pattern of similar claims filed in the Inland Empire region, all involving high-value vehicles and identical descriptions of bear-related damage. Adjusters noted inconsistencies in the claw marks, which appeared too uniform and lacked the variability expected from actual wildlife encounters.
Forensic experts examined the damage patterns and determined the marks were consistent with synthetic bear paws commonly used in costumes or theatrical props. Further investigation led to surveillance footage from a local costume shop showing the purchase of a full bear suit by one of the defendants months before the first claimed incident.
“This was not a case of opportunistic fraud but a deliberate, repeated scheme designed to exploit insurance policies covering comprehensive damage,” said a spokesperson for the California Department of Insurance during the prosecution phase. “The use of a bear costume to simulate wildlife damage was both unusual and indicative of premeditation.”
Impact and Ongoing Vigilance Against Fraud
The case has been cited by state insurance regulators as an example of evolving fraud tactics that require heightened scrutiny, particularly in comprehensive claims involving animal damage or natural causes. Officials emphasized that while such schemes are rare, they underscore the importance of forensic verification in claims processing.
As of the most recent update from the San Bernardino County District Attorney’s Office, all restitution payments have been scheduled, and the defendants remain under court supervision. No appeals have been filed in the case as of this reporting.
Insurance fraud remains a significant concern in California, with the state reporting over $1 billion in suspected fraudulent claims annually across all lines of coverage. Authorities continue to urge vehicle owners and insurers to report suspicious claims, especially those involving unusual circumstances or inconsistent evidence.
If you have information about suspected insurance fraud, you can report it anonymously through the California Department of Insurance’s fraud hotline or online portal.
Stay informed, share this story, and join the conversation below.
