President Donald Trump’s complaints about JD Vance have multiplied in the weeks since the midterm elections, and the vice president’s blunt postmortem on the Republican defeat is at the heart of it.
The New York Times reported, citing unnamed sources, that Trump believes Vance should have defended his decision to go to war with Iran—a war Vance publicly blamed for the GOP’s losses.
The flashpoint was a post Vance wrote on X the morning after Democrats took control of the House and Senate. “The reason we lost is the war,” Vance wrote, adding, “But everyone knows why we lost. And any honest conversation about where we go from here must start there.” The Independent, which quoted the full post, noted the war sent gas prices skyrocketing and cost Republicans the Senate.
Trump brushed the comments off in public. On Nov. 8, he told reporters Vance “was right, other than one thing,” adding that Vance should have answered the question, “If you had to do it again, would you do it again? The answer is yes.” Privately, the president’s grumbling has grown more frequent as November wears on.
What makes this more than palace gossip is who Trump praises while fuming. According to the Times, he has privately complimented Secretary of State Marco Rubio—long positioned against Vance as the likeliest Trump successor—for defending the Iran war. Rubio told reporters that Trump “identified a very real threat…and he addressed it,” even when doing so “isn’t necessarily popular but necessary.”

Rubio in Asia while Vance stays home
The contrast is playing out in real time this week. Rubio is traveling with Trump across Asia, where the president will meet Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin.
Vance, meanwhile, abruptly canceled his appearance at The New York Times’ DealBook summit on Wednesday minutes before it began—host Andrew Ross Sorkin told the audience the vice president was called back to Washington for meetings on the mysterious tech outages that began last week.
The 2028 math turns ugly for Vance
The midterm shellacking has scrambled the succession race. CNN reported last week, citing unnamed allies, that Vance has privately told confidants he is leaning away from a 2028 run—a reconsideration that predated the election, after the birth of his fourth child earlier this year. Vance has set no timeline for deciding, CNN reported.
Some in his circle read the X post differently: as an attempt to put distance between himself and Trump, and a sign he is still seriously weighing a run. Both readings can’t be right, and the ambiguity is the point.
A new Reuters/Ipsos poll suggests the audience hasn’t picked a side either: 62 percent of Americans said Vance would be an excellent or good 2028 candidate, while 58 percent said the same of Rubio. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, emboldened by the midterms, waits in the wings.

Vance’s defense: “no daylight”
Vance pushed back on the tension talk in an interview with Fox News’ Laura Ingraham that aired Monday. “There’s no daylight” between him and the president, he said, adding that when the president decides, “he is owed a Cabinet that helps implement that decision.”
He defended the war’s results—“we have destroyed the nuclear program” and “Iran’s conventional military”—while warning of the pitfalls of a “forever war” and insisting Trump intends to end it.
Trump’s own accounting of the midterms, in a 60 Minutes interview earlier this month, wobbled between concession and deflection. “They didn’t like the war. They didn’t like the fact that gasoline went up,” he told correspondent Ross Douthat—before blaming media coverage and weak Republican candidates, saying, “I think if I was on the ballot, it would have been a much different situation.”
What nobody has settled
The broader realignment of the Make America Great Again movement is underway, and Vance’s standing within it is the open question. He denies a rift. Trump’s complaints, per the Times, continue. And the one thing neither man has said publicly is whether the vice president will run in 2028 at all.