White South Africans who emigrated decades ago are increasingly moving back to their home country, driven by a desire to reconnect with their roots, even as political debates persist over crime rates and land policy.
On June 1, armed men broke into Nico Struwig’s home and forced him to take them to his brother Steve’s house next door, where his brother was shot and killed, PBS News reported.
Right-wing media outlets and figures like Tucker Carlson have characterized such violence as targeted attacks against the white minority, a claim echoed by President Donald Trump in discussions at the White House earlier this year, PBS News reported. Trump’s administration subsequently carved out an exception for white South Africans under a strict ban on refugee admissions.
South Africa’s government rejects allegations that the white minority faces a coordinated campaign of violence. Local civic groups like AfriForum, which brought attention to the farm attacks, state that while the violence is a serious and unique crime, it does not constitute genocide, as Ernst Van Zyl told PBS News.
Critics argue that framing violence as an exceptional threat to white South Africans ignores broader systemic issues. Nicky Falkof, a professor of media studies at the University of the Witwatersrand in Johannesburg, told PBS News that poverty and high inequality fuel the country’s violent crime rate, which predominantly affects poor Black South Africans.
Official statistics show that South Africa recorded 23,642 murders between January and December 2025, averaging 65 murders every day, according to PBS News. By comparison, AfriForum recorded 29 farm murders for 2025, marking a decline from 55 murders in 2021.
Return Migration Gathers Pace
Despite these security challenges, a reverse migration trend is underway as many South Africans who left after the end of apartheid in 1994 decide to return. Natasha Robson-Lovato was 12 years old when her family emigrated to the United States, but three decades later, she returned with her American husband, Jason Lovato, to farm pecans in Gauteng Province, PBS News reported.
Returnees often cite the high cost of living in Western nations as a major factor in their decision to move back. Real estate in South Africa costs a fraction of what returnees from Western countries are used to.
Arts writer Petra Mason returned to South Africa after living for two decades in New York and Miami, telling PBS News that the country’s cultural complexity provides a strong pull. Real estate agents in Johannesburg report an increase in inquiries and purchases from returning expatriates since 2023.
Rory O’Hagan of Chas Everitt International Property Group told PBS News that business has risen sharply from returning South Africans. A Facebook group for returnees, which had under 2,000 members three years ago, has grown to 27,000 members, according to Meg Wilson, a returnee who spoke with PBS News.
| Metric | Data Point | Source / Context |
|---|---|---|
| Total Murders (2025) | 23,642 | South Africa national records (Jan–Dec 2025) |
| Farm Murders (2025) | 29 | AfriForum count |
| Farm Murders (2021) | 55 | AfriForum count |
| Returnee Facebook Group | 27,000 members | Growth from under 2,000 members over three years |
For those moving back, the decision involves weighing ongoing domestic challenges against the personal and financial benefits of returning. “South Africa is the type of country that is so complex and so interesting,” Petra Mason told PBS News. “The draw to be part of the story is enormous.”