10 High-Upside MLB Free Agents With High Risk and Uncertain Projections

MLB teams face uncertainty this offseason as they evaluate 10 marquee free agents whose recent performances have created conflicting projections for their future value, according to MLB.com.

Jazz Chisholm Jr. remains a polarizing talent, combining a lifetime 106 OPS+ with persistent injury issues and a 97 OPS+ during the 2026 season. Despite failing to exceed 137 games in a season since 2024, he stands as one of only eight players to record at least 125 homers and 125 steals over the past six years.

Trent Grisham presents a similar puzzle. After a breakout 2025 campaign with the Yankees, his production dipped during an injury-riddled 2026. MLB.com said that Grisham’s .367 batting average on hard-hit balls in 2026 was the second-worst mark recorded under Statcast tracking since 2015, suggesting his poor results may be tied more to bad luck than a decline in skill.

Several veteran pitchers and position players offer high ceilings alongside significant health risks. Ty France, who signed a Minor League deal with the Padres in February, delivered a career-high 139 OPS+ before reaching free agency. Teams must now determine if his 2026 production is sustainable or if he will regress toward his 98 OPS+ output from 2023-25.

On the mound, injury history complicates the market for several starters. Nick Pivetta, who made only eight starts in 2026 due to a right elbow flexor strain, saw his $14 million club option declined by the Padres. Meanwhile, Jesus Luzardo-era trade candidate Trevor Rogers and right-hander Nick Mahle have both demonstrated extreme inconsistency, with performance swings often tied to midseason trades or recurring physical ailments.

Luis Robert Jr. continues to be defined by his availability, having missed nearly 400 games from 2021-26. While he is only 29 years old, his production has hovered at an 88 OPS+ since 2024. Whether he can return to his 2023 form—when he posted 38 homers and 20 steals—remains the central question for his suitors.

Daulton Varsho and Taylor Ward also highlight the difficulty of predicting offensive output. Varsho’s value remains tied to his elite defensive range, even as his OPS+ dipped to 76 in 2026. Ward, meanwhile, attempted to reinvent himself as a high-OBP hitter in Baltimore before struggling during a 32-game tenure with the Mariners.

Player 2026 OPS+ Context
Jazz Chisholm Jr. 97 Lifetime 106 OPS+
Trent Grisham 95 123 OPS+ in 2025
Ty France 139 Career-high in 2026
Daulton Varsho 76 121 OPS+ in 2025

The market for these players hinges on whether teams are willing to pay for past peaks or if they will prioritize the durability concerns that defined the most recent season.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Turkey Evaluates Saudi Defense Needs, No Troop Deployment to Yemen

Delta Air Lines Delays Over 1,600 Flights After System Outage