Seventy-seven percent of U.S. adults now save holiday gift ideas from online creators, a behavior that has turned social feeds into the season’s dominant shopping list, according to a Center for the Creator Economy survey of 988 adults conducted November 7 and 8.
The finding, released by the Syracuse University-based center, shows creator content has displaced traditional retail circulars as the primary discovery engine for most Americans. Half of respondents bought at least one creator-recommended gift last holiday season, and 61 percent say they are likely to do so again this year, Futurity reported. Among those who purchased on a creator’s suggestion last season, purchase intent rises to 85 percent.
“Holiday shopping used to start with a store circular or a retailer’s email. Now, for most Americans, it starts with a saved post,” said Ryan Schram, executive director of the Center for the Creator Economy.
Instagram (60 percent), YouTube (59 percent), and TikTok (53 percent) lead as the platforms where users store these ideas. Women and adults aged 18 to 44 are the most active savers, with 65 percent of all respondents saving ideas for others and 47 percent saving for both themselves and other people.
Trust Gap: Paid Ads Versus Free Product
Consumers report a clear-eyed view of the commercial nature of creator content. Seventy percent agree that creators’ holiday deal promotions are “mostly just advertising,” yet 53 percent say creators help them find deals “actually worth it,” according to the center’s flash report.
A trust asymmetry emerges when disclosure mechanisms differ. Fifty-six percent of respondents feel very or extremely confident spotting a paid promotion, but only 45 percent feel that sure when a creator promotes a product received for free from a brand. The Federal Trade Commission requires clear disclosure of both material connections, yet the data suggests audiences distinguish the transparency of the two formats.
Creators also act as negative filters. Sixteen percent of respondents said a creator talked them out of a gift last season, most often by pointing to a better-quality alternative (38 percent) rather than a cheaper one (25 percent) or dismissing the product entirely (23 percent).
Trust Hierarchy: Creators Near Brands, Above AI
Friends and family remain the gold standard, with 75 percent trusting them “very much” or “completely” for gift recommendations. Customer reviews follow at 48 percent. Creators (53 percent) now nearly match brands (55 percent) for moderate-or-higher trust, while significantly outranking artificial intelligence tools (24 percent trust not at all) and celebrities (39 percent trust not at all), the survey found.
Beauty and personal care, clothing and accessories, electronics, and home and kitchen lead the categories influenced by creator recommendations. Women were more likely than men to say they would buy beauty and personal care products based on a creator’s suggestion and more likely to save creator gift ideas generally, news.syr.edu reported.
Creator Posts Replace Circulars for Holiday Shopping
- Social media feeds have replaced store circulars as the starting point for holiday shopping for over three-quarters of U.S. adults.
- Shoppers know creator posts are ads, but trust them nearly as much as brands—especially for beauty, tech, and home goods.
- Disclosure gaps persist: audiences spot paid ads more easily than “free product” arrangements, a distinction regulators watch closely.
Creator-Driven Buyers Convert on Black Friday and Cyber Monday
The survey captures the compression of the purchase funnel. Thirty-seven percent of last season’s creator-driven buyers purchased on Black Friday and 26 percent on Cyber Monday, indicating creators drive both consideration and conversion during peak promotional windows. The “save” function across Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok operates as a persistent, cross-session cart that bridges discovery in November to purchase in late November.
The Center for the Creator Economy, launched in November 2025, is the first academic center of its kind, co-led by the S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications and the Martin J. Whitman School of Management at Syracuse University. Its interdisciplinary work spans independent industry research, policy engagement, and support for student and alumni ventures.
In April 2026, the center introduced the university’s first formal academic offering from its work: a minor in the creator economy integrating courses from Newhouse, Whitman, and other schools. The center also opened its physical home at the Newhouse School in spring 2026, featuring collaboration and production spaces.
Contraindications & When to Consult a Professional
| Trust Source | Moderate+ Trust (%) | Trust “Not at All” (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Friends & Family | 75 | — |
| Customer Reviews | 48 | — |
| Brands | 55 | — |
| Creators | 53 | — |
| AI Tools | — | 24 |
| Celebrities | — | 39 |
The center’s second monthly flash report is available for download on its website.
References
- Syracuse University. November 2026.
- Futurity. 77% of US adults surveyed save holiday gift ideas from online creators.
- Save, Trust, Buy: Creators Drive Holiday Gift Ideas for 77% of U.S. Adults Surveyed.