Aaron Sorkin’s A Few Good Men has returned to the stage in a Michael Arden-directed revival at the Vivian Beaumont Theater at LCT, and StageBuddy’s review finds the military courtroom drama fascinating but smaller than the 1992 film.
The production stars Tom Blyth, Bradley Whitford, and Krysta Hernandez.
The problem, as the StageBuddy review frames it, is baked into the premise: people buy tickets because they liked the movie, then arrive at the theater and are often disappointed because the adaptation to the stage doesn’t live up to those expectations.
Sorkin’s story began as a stage play, inspired by a true event his sister, a JAG attorney, told him about, before it became an award-winning movie in 1992. Now it is back onstage where it started, and the comparison is unavoidable.
The story itself continues to fascinate. A Marine private, Santiago, stationed at Gitmo in the 1980s, writes letters begging for a transfer, bypasses his chain of command, and becomes a pariah in his unit.
His squadmates carry out an unwritten punishment, a “Code Red,” and an extenuating medical condition turns a hazing into a death. Did two soldiers act on their own, or were they following orders? StageBuddy recalls the 2025 video in which Senator Mark Kelly and other Democratic lawmakers urged service members to “refuse illegal orders.”
That resonance, the review argues, is what keeps Sorkin’s moral dilemma alive on the Beaumont stage even when the production around it goes soft.
Review Finds Kaffee Lightweight and Jessep Familiar
- The revival is at the Vivian Beaumont Theater at LCT, directed by Michael Arden.
- StageBuddy finds Blyth’s Kaffee “a bit lightweight” at first and never fully dynamic, while Whitford’s Jessep is effective but hard to separate from his other roles.
- What works onstage, per the review, is the pageantry: military drills and Santiago’s funeral fill the wide, deep Beaumont stage.
Three Performances, Three Verdicts
Tom Blyth plays LTJG Daniel Kaffee, the wisecracking young officer who joined the military only to pay for his law degree, and whose assignment is an obvious Navy ploy to speed the case along.
StageBuddy’s verdict: he grows into the role, getting stronger as Kaffee becomes invested, but never quite becomes dynamic. Even Kaffee’s breakthrough in court arrives not through his own legal skill but because Maj. Matthew Martinson, played by Thom Sesma, hands him the evidence he needs.
Nick Blaemire, as LTJG Sam Weinberg, comes off better. Funny yet wise, he offers quiet guidance as Kaffee’s second. Krysta Hernandez, a singing and dancing Broadway veteran, is cast as LCDR Joanne Galloway, and StageBuddy calls her miscast in the heavy dramatic role, insinuating herself into the trial while making a couple of major errors that almost seem to be expected of her character.
Then there is Bradley Whitford as Lt. Col. Nathan R. Jessep, the base commander. A capable, steady performance, the review says, most effective when he digs at Kaffee, calling him “Danny” and advising him to have sex with a superior officer. He is so nasty he is repugnant.
But that creates a structural problem later: it is difficult to accept that this cocky egotist would take Kaffee’s bait so quickly in the courtroom, and at times it is hard to separate Whitford from other roles where he is intelligent, soft-spoken and dependable, not vicious and hostile.
Why the Courtroom Scene Plays Smaller Live
Everything builds toward the famous confrontation, Kaffee against Jessep, working his ego until Jessep explodes. The scene still works, StageBuddy reports, but it lacks the drama of the film. Film allows for close-ups: the anger, the disgust, the emotion in two faces squared off across a courtroom.
The Beaumont stage is wide and deep, and we don’t get the close-ups. The physicality would need to be bigger and more animated to land the same punch, and this production does not deliver the same emotion as in the film version.
That is the honest trade of adaptation, and the review lays it out plainly. Movies use panoramas, special effects, and close-ups that stage shows cannot always replicate, no matter how sophisticated technology becomes.
The two soldiers who carried out the Code Red, played by Lavel Schley and Collin Kelly-Sordelet, understood their orders without them being stated, especially when Lt. Kendrick, played with ferocity by John Zdrojeski, yelled that they should get their house in order. On film, that ambiguity reads in an actor’s eyes. Onstage, it has to be built.
Play Returns Home After Film Fame
| Era | Form | Key Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Stage play | Born from a true event Sorkin’s sister, a JAG attorney, told him about |
| 1992 | Feature film | Award-winning adaptation |
| Now | Stage | Directed by Michael Arden at the Vivian Beaumont Theater at LCT |
The timeline matters because it explains the expectations problem. This is not a movie being adapted for the stage; it is a stage play returning home. Audiences walk in waiting for Jessep’s famous line “you can’t handle the truth.”
And while Arden uses the pageantry of the military, the drills, the funeral, to fill the Beaumont’s vast stage, the review’s central finding is that the material plays smaller in person than it did on screen.
Michael Arden, who directs this revival, has established himself as a significant voice in modern theatre. After receiving a full scholarship to the Juilliard School in 2001, he left the institution in 2003 to join the Broadway revival company of Big River.
His directorial work is particularly notable for the 2015 production of Spring Awakening, which utilized a cast featuring both deaf and hearing actors performing simultaneously in American Sign Language and English. His considerable talent has been recognized with two Tony Awards for Best Direction of a Musical, winning for the productions of Parade in 2023 and Maybe Happy Ending in 2025.
And yet. No matter how good the movie is, StageBuddy concludes, it cannot beat the thrill of a live performance.