Activists Call COP31 ‘Worst Ever’ as Talks Stall on Fossil Fuels

Delegates at the COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, remain deadlocked over fossil fuel phase-outs and climate finance, as two hundred nations struggle to forge a consensus text amid rolling negotiations and departing ministers, according to Radio Canada.

The conference, which extended past its official schedule into the weekend, faced fierce condemnation from civil society groups. Activists and delegates labelled the gathering the worst summit in history due to the complete removal of fossil fuel transition language from early draft agreements.

“Le problème avec la navette diplomatique, c’est qu’il y a très peu de place dedans et beaucoup de passagers en sont exclus,” Caroline Brouillette, directrice générale du Réseau action climat Canada, told La Presse. She explained that the opaque process sought to force a text through the final plenary session while delegates rushed to leave.

Activists Call COP31 'Worst Ever' as Talks Stall on Fossil Fuels
Photo: Le Devoir

Outside the main negotiation halls, physical dismantling of the sprawling venue in suburban Antalya began while observers waited. Discussions faltered repeatedly over major items like the Belém Action Mechanism and global adaptation targets, according to La Presse reporting.

A coalition of approximately twelve nations, including France and Panama, demanded explicit mentions of a transition away from fossil fuels after previous drafts remained entirely silent on the matter. Meanwhile, structural disagreements persisted between Turkey and Australia regarding their joint COP presidency.

Climate Action Network calls COP31 the worst COP ever — Climate Action Network International

“C’est la pire COP de tous les temps,” Mohamed Adow, directeur et fondateur de l’organisation Power Shift Africa, told La Presse during a press briefing. He questioned the purpose of bringing the global community together if negotiations merely repeated past decisions.

The European Union also criticized the trajectory of the summit, warning that the final outcome risked becoming a fossil fuel summit rather than a decisive step forward. Financial commitments to developing nations were largely deferred to subsidiary meetings in Bonn scheduled for June or to COP32 in Ethiopia.

Monique Barbut - Grandin
Photo: l'Opinion
Core COP31 Target Provisional Metric Timeline & Context
Global Electrification 35% of total final energy consumption Target set for 2035 (up from ~20% currently)
Temperature Cap 1.5°C limit Measured against 1850-1900 pre-industrial baseline
Canadian Emissions Trend 10.3% below 2005 levels Reported in the plus récent inventaire national for 2024
Projected Reduction Gap Plafonds at 28% in 2030 Estimated by the commissaire à l’environnement et au développement durable

Substantive progress occurred largely outside official negotiation rooms. Roughly 25 states advanced independent roadmaps to curtail hydrocarbon reliance, and nearly 90 countries adopted a target to electrify 35 percent of their energy consumption by 2035.

Antalya, Turkey, sits on Anatolia’s southwest coast flanked by the Taurus Mountains, with an urban population around 1.5 million and a provincial population of 2,722,103.

Founded around 200 BC as Attaleia by King Attalus II of Pergamon, it later became a major Roman port and Byzantine naval station before passing to the Seljuk Empire in 1207 and the Ottomans in 1391. In 2023 it attracted more than 16.5 million foreign visitors, ranking as the fourth-most visited city in the world.

“Cette COP n’est pas en train de mourir, elle en train d’être assassinée,” Anabella Rosemberg, conseillère principale sur la transition juste du Réseau action climat international, told La Presse.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Hunger Games Prequel Opens to $56M, Projected $120M Weekend per Variety