Advent as Lamaze: Maternal Mental Health, Forgiveness, and Divine Midwifery

In an Advent devotional column titled “Just Keep Breathing,” published this week by Sojourners magazine, the writer argues that the season’s themes of pregnancy, labor, and birth offer a framework for thinking about maternal mental health, forgiveness, and the support systems that fail vulnerable mothers.

The column ties the waiting of Advent to the physical and emotional strain of childbirth — and to one of the most disturbing maternal mental health trials in recent memory.

The writer, an adoptive mother, opens by insisting that the imagery of the season is not reserved for those who have given birth. Anyone of any gender, with or without a uterus, with or without kids can ask, she writes, what wants to be born through them this year. She frames Advent itself as childbirth preparation: Advent is a Lamaze class, and we are all getting ready.

That framing becomes pointed in the column’s first full week of reflections, dated December 6, where the writer connects the Advent theme of forgiveness to the trial of Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts mother charged with murdering her children.

Sojourners reports that the writer followed the trial “like many mothers,” noting that Clancy’s attorneys argued an insanity defense rooted in postpartum psychosis — a rare but documented perinatal psychiatric emergency in which a mother can lose touch with reality.

Why a devotional took up a criminal trial

The column does not treat the case as a legal commentary. It treats it as a test of what forgiveness actually costs. What stirs inside your body if we say Lindsay Clancy is forgiven? the writer asks readers. If forgiveness doesn’t feel guttural, I’m not sure we understand the word yet.

The writer is careful, in her own words, to hold two things at once. She writes that she grieves the loss of innocent children and “ferociously” believes all children deserve protection. At the same time, she argues the trial exposed inadequate support systems for maternal mental health — and an inequity in how that compassion is distributed.

She points to the case of Latarsha Sanders, another mother whose case she cites, and writes that the conversation about maternal health tends to be much more forgiving of white women than Black mothers.

The column grounds its argument in scripture rather than in clinical literature, but the medical reality it gestures toward is well established. Postpartum psychosis affects a small fraction of new mothers, and the mismatch between need and treatment — screening, access to perinatal psychiatric care, and equitable application of that care across race — is precisely the “inadequate support system” the writer names.

Her claim that the system’s mercy is unevenly applied is a claim about society, not medicine, but it rests on the same clinical fact: mothers in psychiatric crisis are falling through systems that were supposed to catch them.

Postpartum psychosis differs from depression and demands equal care

  • Postpartum psychosis is real and rare. It is a psychiatric emergency distinct from the far more common postpartum depression, and it can involve losing touch with reality — the defense argued in the Clancy trial.
  • Support systems, not just symptoms, are the issue. The writer’s argument is that outcomes depend on whether mothers get timely screening and care — and whether that care is offered equally across race.
  • Forgiveness and accountability are being held together. The column does not ask readers to excuse harm; it asks what compassion costs when a mother’s mind failed her.

Midwives to each other

The December 13 reflection shifts from the courtroom to the community. The writer describes a group of women preparing a sermon on Mary’s Magnificat and noticing that the standard lectionary reading cuts off the verse’s first words: “Mary said.” Restoring those words, she writes, restores the credit — it was Mary, not an angel, who sang the prophecy, and it was her encounter with Elizabeth, a woman-to-woman meeting, that “activated” her voice.

From that detail the writer draws a social prescription: How might we be midwives to each other, midwives to the emerging prophet within? She asks readers to name who prepared the way for them — who saw them, restored their capacity to dream, filled their mouths with laughter — and to whom they are now being sent.

The observation that recognition by another person is what frees a voice reads, in a health context, as an argument for the kind of peer and community support that clinical screening alone cannot supply.

The vulnerable choice

In the December 20 reflection, the writer contrasts King David, who wanted to build God a secure temple, with the story she says God actually chose: arriving as a baby carried in a young, unmarried mother’s body.

Strength is soft, not wooden, she writes. Bendable. Fleshy. Human. The column calls Mary’s consent “audacious bravery” and asks what it means to be a Mary in a world full of Davids — to make the vulnerable choice rather than the showy one.

The final week, dated December 27, turns to the aging prophets Simeon and Anna and their foreboding words to Mary: “A sword will pierce your soul.” The writer extends that entanglement to everyone.

If Paul’s adoption language means human suffering is felt in the body of God, she argues, then salvation is not rescue from vulnerability but company within it. You are not, have never been, will never be alone, she concludes.

Week Texts Theme the writer draws
December 6 Isaiah 40; Psalm 85; Mark 1 Forgiveness after the Lindsay Clancy trial; maternal mental health inequity
December 13 Isaiah 61; Luke 1:46-55; John 1 Mary’s silenced words; mutual “midwifery” of each other’s voices
December 20 2 Samuel 7; Luke 1:26-38 Vulnerability over fortress; strength as softness
December 27 Isaiah 61; Galatians 4; Luke 2 Interdependence; God bound to human suffering and joy

Column is reflection not clinical guidance; seek help for harmful thoughts

The column is a spiritual reflection, not clinical guidance, and readers should treat it as such. But it touches a subject where professional help is genuinely urgent: thoughts of harming oneself or a child after childbirth are a medical emergency, not a moral failing, and warrant immediate contact with a clinician or emergency services.

Persistent postpartum depression, intrusive thoughts, or any loss of touch with reality after delivery should be evaluated by a healthcare provider without delay. The writer’s own framing — that mothers are being failed by inadequate systems — is an argument for seeking that care early, and for communities that make it reachable.

What the column asks for

Read as a whole, the devotional asks readers to sit with discomfort rather than resolve it: to extend a forgiveness that “feels guttural,” to notice whose compassion arrives faster and whose arrives late or not at all, and to become, in the writer’s phrase, midwives to one another.

It does not propose policy. It proposes posture — breathing through the labor of a season that, in her words, leaves the atmosphere still pregnant with love.

The column appears in Sojourners, a progressive Christian magazine first published in 1971 under the title The Post-American, born out of a community of students at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School. In 1975, as that community relocated to Columbia Heights in Washington, D.C., the publication took the name it carries today.

Known for its reporting and commentary on faith and social justice — from poverty and peacemaking to interfaith dialogue — the magazine publishes eleven issues a year, and its founder, Jim Wallis, served on President Barack Obama’s Advisory Council on Faith-Based and Community Partnerships before Adam Russell Taylor succeeded him as president in November 2020.

The closing line of the December 27 entry carries the column’s final word on suffering and company: In the worst of times and the best of times, God stays bound to you.

References

  • Sojourners magazine, “Just Keep Breathing,” Advent devotional column, December 2025 weekly reflections (December 6, 13, 20, 27).
  • Scriptural texts cited within the column: Isaiah 40; Isaiah 61; Psalm 85; Psalm 148; 2 Samuel 7; Luke 1; Luke 2; Galatians 4; 1 Thessalonians 5; 2 Peter 3; Mark 1; John 1.
Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

EU Council Approves Trade and Investment Deals With Indonesia