Adviser Warns Government Risks Missing Climate Targets If EV Rules Weakened

Weakening the UK’s electric car sales rules would probably cost the country its legally binding climate targets, the Climate Change Committee warned on Wednesday, in a letter to Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander.

The committee’s warning lands amid weeks of speculation that the government plans to loosen the zero emission vehicle (ZEV) mandate — the rule requiring carmakers to sell a rising share of electric cars each year or pay £12,000 per vehicle — though government sources insist no decision has been made.

Writing in a letter released on Wednesday, the CCC cautioned that if the UK permits greater sales of petrol and diesel vehicles over the coming four years, its climate targets would probably be missed. The advisers said the changes could add 8.4 million tonnes of CO2 pollution a year by the next decade, and that the electric vehicle rules are the single biggest contributor to the country’s climate goals.

Nigel Topping’s warning to ministers

CCC chair Nigel Topping wrote to Alexander opposing any reduction of the targets, arguing cuts would expose the UK to more volatile oil markets — up to 15 million extra barrels a year by 2030 — and cost Britain over £1 billion a year in oil imports at current prices, according to the committee’s own published analysis.

Brand new cars are lined up in what looks like an inspection area in a car factory. The first car in line is gold
Photo: bbc.co.uk

Weakening the Zero-Emission Vehicle Mandate would miss an opportunity to reduce the cost of living for people, undermine Britain’s competitiveness, and leave us more exposed to volatile fossil fuel prices. People are buying electric vehicles in record numbers because they are cheaper to own than the alternative. The mandate gives those up and down the supply chain the certainty they need to invest, supports thousands of jobs, and keeps the UK on track to meet its climate commitments.

Nigel Topping, Chair of the Climate Change Committee

The committee calculates that a typical household saves around £800 a year by switching to an electric car, money fewer families would save if targets were watered down. It also warned the mandate underpins not only the UK’s Sixth Carbon Budget for 2033 to 2037 but the separate budgets set by Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.

The mandate under pressure

Under the current rules, 80% of new cars sold must be zero emission by 2030, and all new cars by 2035. Carmakers have lobbied for months to cut the 2030 headline target to as low as 50% or 60%, arguing the mandate imposes too much financial pressure.

ZEV mandate sales figures Share
2030 headline target 80% electric
Industry’s requested cut as low as 50% or 60%
2026 headline target 33%
EV share of new sales, first 10 months of 2026 26.6%

Electric cars were 26.6% of UK new car sales in the first ten months of 2026, well below the 33% target. But analysis by New AutoMotive, a transport research organisation, suggests the industry is still on course to comply this year once “flexibilities” — loopholes that let manufacturers count sales in other ways — are accounted for.

The industry pushes back

“The CCC, however, ignores the damaging cost of the targets it defends: billions in unsustainable discounts and millions more in government incentives.”, Mike Hawes, chief executive of the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, accused the CCC of ignoring the cost of the targets it defends.

IJR News story with source-bias breakdown
Photo: ijr.com

The industry cannot subsidise the transition indefinitely, which is why it is unified in seeking change.

Mike Hawes, Chief Executive of the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders

Lord Deben, former CCC chairman, said going against CCC advice would “not be sensible” as it would “cost people money,” and warned that if you don’t reach climate targets “then you put yourselves in really serious danger.”

Government under scrutiny

Government sources insist no decision has been made on whether to change the targets. The committee’s warning concerns what would follow from loosening the vehicle rules; it does not indicate that any such move has actually been decided by the government.

The CCC says the mandate is the single biggest contributor to the government’s climate goals.

What the government says

No statement has come from the government on whether the mandate will be altered, nor on the means by which any emissions savings forfeited under relaxed rules would be made up.

Nigel Topping said that the UK currently ranks 22nd in the world for EV sales, behind key competitor countries for making cars such as France and Germany, and added that the market has already evolved while the UK should be accelerating to keep up rather than putting on the brakes.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Muddy Waters Questions Nvidia Ex-Chief’s Ties to Super Micro Case

ABC Hosts Dolly Tribute at 60th CMA Countdown Special