DWTS Season 35: Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson Shockingly Eliminated After Perfect Semi-Final Scores

Harry Shum Jr. and pro partner Jenna Johnson were eliminated from “Dancing With the Stars” season 35 on Tuesday’s semifinals, despite earning a perfect 60/60 and tying for the top of the leaderboard — one week before the November 24 finale.

It is the second straight week the ballroom has said goodbye to a frontrunner. Last week, Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy were sent home. Now the same math has claimed another couple the judges adored.

The fact is: the “Glee” alum and Johnson didn’t just score well. They scored flawlessly, twice, on a night packed with perfect marks.

Five Couples Advance to the Finale

  • Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson went home with a perfect 60/60 — the cruelest possible exit.
  • Five couples advance to the November 24 finale, which airs live on both coasts at 8 p.m. ET. ET/5 p.m. PT.
  • Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov join Shum at the top of the semifinal leaderboard, also at 60/60.

Shum Performs to Naya Rivera Song

The Tuesday, November 17 semifinal dropped its usual theme. As reported, the six remaining couples chose their own music and performed two routines each — one ballroom style, one Latin. Twelve dances later, five couples had finale tickets and the show’s most consistent frontrunner did not.

DWTS Season 35: Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson Shockingly Eliminated After Perfect Semi-Final Scores
Photo: TODAY

Shum and Johnson opened with a paso doble to Rihanna’s “We Found Love” for a 30/30, then closed the night with a quickstep to “Valerie” — specifically the version sung by Naya Rivera, his “Glee” co-star.

“to be able to dance to Naya’s version, it means so much to so many people, including myself,” Shum said.

The elimination stunned the judges, too. The camera caught Carrie Ann Inaba visibly shocked as the result was read. Shum, fighting back tears beside him, earned a tearful tribute from his partner — and turned the moment back on her.

“I want to say, you have been dealing with everything with grace, with the noise outside and teaching me the things that I have only dreamed of to learn and this has been one of the most beautiful experiences, so thank you so much,” Shum told Johnson.

How the Leaderboard Shook Out

Three couples hit 30/30 in round one: Shum and Johnson’s paso doble, Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas’s samba, and Olympic figure skater Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov’s salsa to Celia Cruz’s “Bemba Colorá.”

Paralympian Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach earned a score of 27/30 for their quickstep to 3 Doors Down’s “Kryptonite” with Bruno Tonioli comparing him to Mikhail Baryshnikov. Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik also landed 27/30 for a waltz to Journey’s “Open Arms.”

Round two delivered more fireworks. Frech swung from all nines to all tens with a jive to “Footloose,” his first perfect score. Glenn matched Shum’s 60 with a Viennese waltz to Ariana Grande’s “Dangerous Woman.”

Higgins and Ballas waltzed to Hozier’s “Shrike” — a song the singer personally blessed during rehearsals, telling them, “I’m honored that you chose it” — for 29/30, after Carrie Ann Inaba docked one point. Ali earned her first 10 from Inaba for a cha, finishing at 28/30. Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold posted 24/30 in both rounds for a total of 48.

Couple Round 1 Round 2 Total
Amber Glenn & Pasha Pashkov 30 30 60
Harry Shum Jr. & Jenna Johnson (ELIMINATED) 30 30 60
Maura Higgins & Mark Ballas 30 29 59
Ezra Frech & Daniella Karagach 27 30 57
Connor Wood & Rylee Arnold 24 24 48

Why a Perfect Score Could Not Save Them

But the math tells a different story. Elimination on “DWTS” combines judges’ scores with viewer votes, and the audience simply didn’t show up for Shum and Johnson the way the scoreboard did. TVLine argued the back-to-back exits of Dewan and Shum might reshape season 36 casting because “the people yearn for true amateurs.”

There is a structural wrinkle, too, and the show just fixed it. Because live voting has historically closed during the East Coast broadcast, West Coast fans were effectively locked out.

Co-host Alfonso Ribeiro announced the November 24 finale will air live coast-to-coast at 5 p.m. PT. PT/8 p.m. The show airs ET on ABC and Disney+, letting Western viewers vote in real time, with streaming available the next day on Hulu.

DWTS Season 35: Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson Shockingly Eliminated After Perfect Semi-Final Scores
Photo: TVLine

For the finale itself, the five couples — Higgins, Frech, Glenn, Ali, and Wood — will face a judges’ choice round, an instant dance, and the freestyle. Every eliminated celebrity, from Jenna Dewan to Guillermo Rodriguez to Julia Stiles, returns for one last turn.

The five couples standing have six Mirrorball trophies between their pros. The man who may have danced the best all season will be watching from home.

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Lithuanian Car of the Year 2027 Test Shows Gap in Usability Times