The All Blacks have publicly backed rugby’s match officials in the hip-drop and knee-drop tackle controversy, rejecting Springboks coach Rassie Erasmus’ claim that referees ignored up to 17 illegal tackles — a claim that on Tuesday earned the 54-year-old a six-match ban from World Rugby after South Africa’s 21-19 defeat to France.
The contrast could hardly be sharper. Erasmus, speaking at a news conference in Dublin on Monday before Saturday’s Nations Championship clash with Ireland, went as far as to ask whether the TMO’s inaction constituted match-fixing. The All Blacks, who themselves lost to Wales in Cardiff on Sunday, took a different line entirely. Hooker Asafo Aumua told 1News the officials were, for the most part, on point.
“I think there were a few missed ones on the weekend, but that wasn’t going to really change the result in the game,” Aumua told 1News. “I feel like they’re [match officials] doing enough, we’ve just got to be a bit more accurate in our tackles.”
SA Rugby has condemned any form of online trolling of officials – more here: https://t.co/BmQIYwzB9N pic.twitter.com/wiR1OPnC6J
That admission carries weight, because Aumua was describing his own technique. He conceded he may have been guilty of two contentious tackles at Principality Stadium — not deliberately, he stressed, but a byproduct of being beaten on the outside and swinging around the ball-carrier.
Captain Beauden Barrett had questioned referee Pierre Brousset several times during the Wales defeat over suspected hip tackles on his teammates. The All Blacks’ camp, in short, sees a technique problem, not a conspiracy.
Assistant coach Mike Blair declined to even litigate the point. “I had a fair bit on my hands after the Wales game, from looking at our attack and I didn’t have time to look at these tackles,” Blair told 1News. “I see Rassie has had a few comments on it, so let him do what he does and I’ll stick to trying to sort our attack out again.”

Erasmus Predicts Prendergast Cleared on Technicality
- Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast, cited for a hip-drop tackle against Fiji, is a genuine availability question for the Aviva Stadium fixture — Erasmus publicly predicted he would be cleared to play “on a technicality.”
- With the ban set to expire during next year’s Rugby Championship, South Africa’s coaching structure faces disruption through the Nations Championship finals and the start of their title defence build-up.
But the tape tells a messier story than either camp admits. World Rugby made hip and knee-drop tackles illegal only on November 1, meaning players and officials are barely three weeks into enforcement.
The knee-drop — a defender initiating the tackle from one or both knees — and the hip tackle, where a defender’s weight lands on an attacker’s lower limbs, are exactly the sort of dynamic, split-second techniques that Aumua described as hard to avoid in contact.
Leroy Carter’s ankle surgery after a hip tackle in October’s Bledisloe Cup win at Eden Park is the injury cost that made the law change urgent in the first place, RNZ reported.
Erasmus’ specific grievance concerns the Paris Test, where he says TMO Matteo Liperini failed to intervene on up to 17 knee-drop tackles by France.
The Guardian’s analysis offers a middle reading: yes, some French tacklers had knees on the ground in the final quarter, but the officiating team appeared to have decided against defining a superb contest with a late arbitrary penalty. As The Guardian put it, only “in the eyes of a practised agent provocateur” does that arithmetic become match-fixing.
Rassie Erasmus banned for six matches after explosive comments in Dublin on Monday. More on the Springboks boss' suspension here: https://t.co/XB7xoSBmk7
Here is what the analytics of this saga actually show: this is the third sanction of Erasmus’ career on this exact front. In 2021, as South Africa’s director of rugby, he served a two-month ban after posting an hour-long video attacking the refereeing in the Lions series defeat — a video World Rugby found contained “multiple abusive and insulting comments and attacks on the officials,” the BBC reported.
In 2022 came a two-match ban for tweets criticising officials after a France loss, posts that precipitated an online pile-on against referee Wayne Barnes. The latest six-match ban falls under the Match Official Abuse Sanction Process World Rugby introduced in July, a framework designed to counter what the governing body calls an unacceptable increase in abuse and threats towards officials.
The escalation is clear: two matches, to six. And the pattern of consequence extends beyond the coach. The Telegraph, comparing Erasmus to “the Donald Trump of rugby,” notes that referee Nic Berry and his family received multiple death threats after the 2021 video.
This week, SA Rugby itself was forced to condemn reports of threats and abusive conduct directed at World Rugby officials, while warning that a large volume of AI-generated commentary about the case was circulating that did not reflect the facts.
The front-office mechanics matter here too. South Africa Rugby has confirmed it will appeal and has requested a full misconduct hearing for Erasmus to “contextualise his comments and assure the panel that it was not his intention to allege that any match official had acted with ulterior motives,” per the BBC.
If the suspension is upheld, he misses Saturday’s Test against Ireland in Dublin (16:40 GMT), next week’s finals weekend fixture at Twickenham’s Allianz Stadium, and the start of the Rugby Championship next summer — returning only in time to prepare the World Cup title defence in Australia, which begins next October.
Erasmus also loaded the pre-Ireland week with a second grenade, predicting Prendergast would escape punishment despite what Erasmus called a “terrible” hip-drop against Fiji — a remark The Telegraph argues placed the independent disciplinary panel in an invidious, bordering-on-impossible position. Ireland coach Andy Farrell has won three of his five meetings against the Springboks, per Sky Sports, and the rivalry’s intensity makes any officiating narrative a live wire.
World Rugby says that Rassie Erasmus "is entitled to have the matter referred to a full misconduct hearing." So waiting to hear whether he will contest the six-game suspension.
So who gains and who loses?
The next move belongs to the misconduct hearing, where Erasmus will argue his words were taken out of context. SA Rugby has not confirmed when that process will commence, with Erasmus likely absent from matchday proceedings when South Africa face Ireland in Dublin on Saturday.

Disclaimer: The fantasy and market insights provided are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute financial or betting advice.