Analysis: California Billionaires Defeated Wealth Tax, Showing Political Power

California voters rejected Proposition 40, a one-off 5% tax on the wealth of the state’s billionaires, in the recent US midterm elections, The Conversation reported.

The measure, sponsored by a Californian trade union, had begun with majority support in early opinion polling — but it ended not only defeated, but followed by a constitutional amendment banning new taxes on wealth in the state.

The billionaires who fought the tax waged what the analysis described as a furious campaign, spending US$378 million to defeat it. Supporters of the measure raised only US$33.5 million.

Writing on November 18, Henry Maher, a lecturer in politics at the University of Sydney, argued the outcome showed the measure’s opponents were able to effectively veto it even in a “blue tsunami” of Democratic victories. Had the proposal been an attempt to rein in the extreme wealth of California’s billionaires, he wrote, it had instead ended up proving their political power.

California voters reject measure to tax the wealth of billionaires — FRANCE 24 English

The key difference in California, according to the analysis, was that the ballot proposal targeted wealth rather than income. Billionaires have a myriad of options to shield their wealth from income taxes, but a wealth tax is much harder to avoid — making it a more radical challenge to the concentration of wealth and power in the United States, and drawing a much more coordinated response.

The midterms also showed the relationship between big money and political power is not always straightforward. Elon Musk spent US$474 million supporting Republican candidates, to very little effect, while in other states measures increasing income taxes on the wealthy mostly succeeded.

An attempt to tax us billionaires has failed it says a lot
Photo: khanlist.com

Maher placed the California result in the context of what political economists describe as a “Medici cycle”, in which economic power is used to acquire political power, which in turn generates more economic power. Its power originally derived from the Medici bank, which at its height was the largest in Europe, though the family’s interests soon grew beyond banking: using their economic wealth, the Medici acquired political power in Florence, which they then used to protect and extend the family’s economic power.

Maher has observed the same cycle closer to home, in the Australian mining sector, where the largest mining corporations used their economic wealth to rewrite the sector’s tax policies, producing even further concentrations of corporate wealth and power.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Lincoln Man Arrested for Sexual Assault of 15-Year-Old Girl in Roca