Umno cannot hope that electors will acknowledge its time in power while simultaneously deflecting blame for mishaps that occurred under its watch, political analyst Mazlan Ali noted.
According to Mazlan Ali from Universiti Teknologi Malaysia speaking to Free Malaysia Today, pointing the finger at select officials or corporate heads falls short when key leadership posts and pivotal decisions fell under the direct responsibility of ministers belonging to the party.
“Political accountability differs from legal liability,” he said, adding that allowing court proceedings to take their course did not remove the party’s responsibility to acknowledge weaknesses in political oversight.
Highlighting cases like 1MDB, Tabung Haji, and the littoral combat ship initiative, Mazlan said that their enduring monetary and defense consequences keep them pertinent for citizens evaluating the organisation’s fitness to rule. He maintained that these incidents transcend bygone disputes, noting that their effects still linger on the nation’s treasury and strategic strengths.
Umno needed to demonstrate genuine renewal rather than rely on its governing experience, according to Mazlan. To achieve this, figures untainted by historic scandals must be given wider pathways to rise, alongside a push for increased openness in internal party ballots.
“Umno needs to establish a clear policy regarding the suspension or expulsion of members convicted of corruption or abuse of power without political compromise,” he said.
He further mentioned that the faction ought to champion more rigorous screening for cabinet and state-linked firm selections, clearer bidding processes, and policy changes to curb unchecked ministerial authority.
Universiti Malaya’s Awang Azman Pawi expressed that casting Umno’s extensive history in government purely through the lens of scandals like Tabung Haji or 1MDB—or letting isolated actions brand the entire collective—would lack fairness.
“We must distinguish between individual wrongdoing, institutional weaknesses and the broader contributions of a political party,” Awang Azman told Free Malaysia Today, pointing to contributions made to education, rural development, industrialisation and institutions such as Felda and Mara.
Accountability standards must apply equally to every administration rather than change according to political convenience, he said. Nevertheless, Awang Azman said Umno must not use its record of contributions to national development to avoid explaining weaknesses in governance and oversight.
“Umno’s historical record remains an asset, provided it can demonstrate that the party has learned from its shortcomings,” he added.