Analysts Weigh Russia’s Potential Power Shifts After Putin

According to exiled Russian journalist and analyst Alexandra Prokopenko, Russia has become so accustomed to violence that it has lost familiarity with normal democratic practices.

Big business figures inside the aggressor state are quietly reflecting on the country’s future after Vladimir Putin leaves power and exploring the possibility of restoring their political influence, BBC News reported, citing analysts who monitor Russia’s business elites.

Following the start of Russia’s full-scale war against Ukraine, the Kremlin kept big business subordinate through a strict policy of rewards and punishments. The state confiscated property from war critics, whereas obedient business owners obtained lucrative military-linked government contracts.

Forbes data indicates that Russia counts 155 billionaires among its population, with their collective fortunes totaling nearly $700 billion. Dmitry Nekrasov, an opposition politician and former Kremlin adviser, pointed out that the financial standing of numerous corporate leaders relies heavily on Putin, government orders, and official patronage.

In his view, owners of substantial liquid funds may prepare more actively for a struggle for influence, while businesspeople dependent on the state risk losing everything.

If Putin resigned or died in office, the prime minister, Mikhail Mishustin, would take over under constitutional rules. Mishustin has not exhibited any presidential ambitions, which analysts note is likely a key reason he was appointed to the post. That dynamic would leave a power vacuum at the top of the Russian state, leaving observers to weigh multiple divergent paths for the regime.

Russian tycoons consider future after pu
Photo: UA.NEWS

Democratic Shift Versus Autocratic Continuity

Some observers in the West and within Russia hope that democracy might flourish in a post-Putin nation, with a government led by the people rather than a new cadre of oligarchs or a single autocrat. Analysts consider this option the least likely path because key democratic institutions have been eroded or destroyed throughout Putin’s long rule. Prokopenko highlighted this institutional decay in her assessments of the country’s political readiness.

Another potential path involves the continuation of authoritarian rule under a different figure who would maintain the established culture of repression. Prokopenko thinks this transition would not immediately take the form of another strongman dictatorship. These systems take time to consolidate, she noted, suggesting that at first, Putin’s successor would likely be weaker than him and command fewer resources.

A third scenario entails tycoons reasserting their power and returning Russia to something resembling a 1990s-style system of oligarchy. Nekrasov explained that under this outcome, the country would be governed by a handful of powerful elite clans acting in alliance with commercial interests. This option remains the preferred outcome for many tycoons.

Tycoons Seek Rule Restoration

Having spent considerable time conversing with Russia’s wealthiest individuals, Prokopenko informed BBC News that affluent elites yearn for a restoration of the era when their opinions mattered, their properties remained secure, and they possessed a clear grasp of operational guidelines.

Already, some wealthy figures are trying to be friends with the right sort of security officials or ministers, according to Nekrasov. He added that any further political steps remain far too dangerous to take under current conditions. Russian wealthy individuals are unlikely to openly speak out against the current authorities due to deep-seated fears of imprisonment and asset forfeiture.

Scenario Primary Driver Institutional Status
Democratic Transition Popular Governance Institutions Eroded/Destroyed
Autocratic Succession Weaker Successor Repression Maintained
Oligarchic Revival Elite Clans and Tycoons Business-State Alliance

Andrey Melnichenko Advocates for Political Changes in Russia

The BBC drew attention to an interview given by Russian billionaire Andrey Melnichenko to The Economist. Rather than demanding Putin’s resignation, he proposed reforms aimed at concluding one-man governance in Russia while fostering deeper international ties for the nation.

Journalist Arkady Ostrovsky raised the possibility that Melnichenko was voicing opinions shared by other business leaders in addition to his own perspectives. At the same time, analysts say that some wealthy Russians would like less repression, freer expression of opinions, and greater political competition.

“They’d like to return to a time when they were listened to, when they were not stripped of assets and when they understood the rules of the game,” said Alexandra Prokopenko, an exiled Russian journalist and analyst.

Photo of author

Alexandra Hartman Editor-in-Chief

Editor-in-Chief Prize-winning journalist with over 20 years of international news experience. Alexandra leads the editorial team, ensuring every story meets the highest standards of accuracy and journalistic integrity.

Éducation Expert Critiques Quebec High School Rankings

Don Hertzfeldt Interview: On His New Film ‘Paper Trail’ and the Soul of Animation