Apple will stand trial in a French criminal court over iPhone parts pairing, facing a fine of up to 5 percent of its revenue — and, if convicted, the world’s first judgment for repair obstruction.
Four days of hearings open on June 17, 2027.
The Paris prosecutor’s office has referred the company to the tribunal correctionnel for obstructing the repair and refurbishment of its iPhones, korben.info reported. The case targets 24 models sold between November 2021 and July 2024, a list that runs from the iPhone XS to the iPhone 15 Pro Max, taking in the SE 2020 and 2022 and the iPhone 12, 13 and 14.
Per france-jeunes.net, no company has ever been prosecuted in France on the repair-obstruction offenses created by the anti-waste law that took effect in 2021 — until now.
The complaint dates back to December 7, 2022. It was filed by Halte à l’obsolescence programmée (HOP), the same association that forced Apple to pay 25 million euros in 2020 over iOS updates that slowed older iPhones, according to Korben. France’s consumer-protection authority, the DGCCRF, then spent four years investigating.
The deliberate-obsolescence offense has existed for over a decade in French law and has never convicted anyone.

What parts pairing actually does to an iPhone
The technical core of the case is serialization, or “pairing.” Each component — display, battery, front camera — carries a serial number stored on a microchip, and the phone’s logic board checks that identifier against its own records. If the match fails, iOS degrades the device.
Swap a screen at an independent shop and the phone flags an “unknown part” alert, can kill True Tone, and can hide the battery-health readout. Replace the selfie camera and Face ID shuts off entirely.
Here’s the part that should worry Apple’s lawyers: these penalties also hit genuine, original parts — identical in every physical respect — installed outside Apple’s authorized channels, because the software never validated the intervention. That is the fact korben.info’s reporting treats as hardest to explain to a judge: an iPhone refusing to display its own battery status after receiving a part identical to the original.
HOP’s 60-page complaint, as detailed by france-jeunes.net, includes an iPhone XR whose touchscreen became unusable after the iOS 16 update. Downgrading to iOS 15 fixed it — but Apple did not permit the downgrade.
The price gap behind the prosecution
HOP’s reasoning is economic as much as ecological. Pairing funnels repairs back to the Apple Store, where a screen replacement costs 489 euros. The French average at independent shops: 161 euros. A captive, dissuasively priced repair pushes owners toward replacement — and roughly 80 percent of a smartphone’s environmental footprint comes from manufacturing, per the association’s filing. Nearly 4 million iPhones are sold in France each year.
Apple contests “firmly these unfounded allegations,” per both outlets. Its spokesperson offered a line that korben.info found striking given the circumstances: “the best repair is the one you never need.”
How the case got here
The 2015 energy-transition law created the offense of planned obsolescence — deliberately shortening a product’s life to boost replacement — carrying two years’ imprisonment and a 300,000-euro fine, scalable to 5 percent of average annual revenue.
The 2021 anti-waste law added a distinct layer at articles L. 441-3 and L. 441-4 of the consumer code: obstructing repair and refurbishment outside the authorized channel, and blocking access to spare parts and repair information. It is this second, untested layer that now anchors the prosecution.
- 2020 — Apple pays HOP 25 million euros over throttling updates on older iPhones.
- November 2021 – July 2024 — the 24 targeted iPhone models are sold; the AGEC repair-obstruction offenses enter into force in 2021.
- December 7, 2022 — HOP files its complaint; Apple launches its Self Service Repair program in France late that year.
- 2024 — iOS gains a dedicated Repair Assistant mode; used genuine parts become eligible.
- November 17, 2026 — the AFP reveals the criminal referral, citing a source close to the case; HOP hails it the same day.
- June 17, 2027 — four days of hearings begin at the tribunal correctionnel de Paris.
Note that Apple has moved since the complaint was filed. Self Service Repair arrived in France in late 2022, second-hand genuine parts are now accepted, and iOS has shipped a repair mode since 2024, according to France Jeunes. HOP acknowledges the shift — and wants to see whether it holds.
A first test for a dormant statute
The referral is not a conviction. Apple is presumed innocent and will not have to answer before June 2027, france-jeunes.net notes. The prosecution must also prove intent, and it faces the legal apparatus of the world’s most valuable company.
But the statute’s dormancy is precisely what gives the trial its weight: whatever the tribunal decides will set the interpretive precedent for L. 441-3 and L. 441-4, and by extension for every hardware maker that pairs parts to logic boards — a practice now common across laptops, consoles and connected devices.
“A conviction for planned obsolescence through repair obstruction would be a historic first in France and in the world,” said Laetitia Vasseur, co-founder of HOP.
The next dated step is on the calendar: four days of pleadings at the Paris criminal court, starting June 17, 2027.