Argon isotopes in the atmospheres of Uranus and Neptune could reveal whether the two ice giants hide vast amounts of rock beneath their thick envelopes — that is the proposal in a new paper by Olivier Mousis of the Southwest Research Institute and co-authors, published in The Planetary Science Journal.
The work lays out a measurement method for a future spacecraft rather than reporting a measurement made at the planets.
The question it targets is deceptively simple. Astronomers have long sorted the outer planets into two camps: Jupiter and Saturn, the gas giants made mostly of hydrogen and helium, and Uranus and Neptune, the much smaller ice giants packed with heavier elements.
But whether those heavier elements are dominated by ice or by rock has never been settled, and no probe can drill into them to find out. Universe Today reported the debate continues, and that researchers need indirect clues.
Mousis and his team think a noble gas holds the answer. Argon-40 forms when potassium-40, an unstable form of a common element, decays. Most of that decay happens in rocks. The argon then seeps out into the atmosphere of its host planet. Universe Today said the gas makes up around 1% of the air on Earth.
The same process could take place inside Uranus and Neptune over billions of years. Measure enough argon-40 in their atmospheres, the model suggests, and it could serve as a rough gauge of how much rock lies below.
The catch: argon has two birthplaces
There is a problem, and it is a serious one. Rocks are not the only source of argon-40. According to Universe Today, a considerable quantity of the isotope was already present in the gas-and-dust cloud from which the Sun and its planets took shape.
Some of that residual argon may have been captured by the young Uranus and Neptune, meaning it could appear in their atmospheres with no connection to rock at all.
The amount captured hinges on where the planets took shape in relation to the “argon ice line” — this is the region where temperatures of around 23-35 Kelvin cause argon to freeze or become locked inside water ice.
Researchers still disagree about where the ice giants formed. Should they have emerged near the Sun and later drifted to more distant orbits, they might have taken on only a small amount of argon, leaving rock as the main source of what sits in their air.
Should they have wandered during their early history, they likely absorbed a great deal, in which case argon-40 by itself would reveal little about a rocky interior. Universe Today reported that a trace gas could help explain how Uranus and Neptune formed, and could also give a misleading answer about what lies deep inside them.
Argon-36 as the control group
The workaround is elegant. Argon-36 is a lighter, non-radioactive form that does not come from decaying rock. Universe Today compared measuring it to having a control group. Since researchers already possess independent estimates of the argon-40 to argon-36 ratio in the primordial solar system, the measured quantity of argon-36 would help indicate how much argon-40 the planets took in when they formed, apart from whatever rock supplied.
The logic runs in two directions. Should a probe detect a large surplus of argon-36 compared with the solar system’s starting material, that would signal a sizable inherited reservoir — and would raise the odds that inherited argon-40 is hiding the contribution from rock.
If argon-36 shows little enrichment, the story changes. A sizable portion of atmospheric argon-40 might come from argon produced by radioactive decay, possibly even the majority of it. Under those conditions, the measurement could still help constrain the rocky component.
One complication the model has to handle: atmospheric measurements therefore need models that connect a local sample with the rest of the planet. Recent work on carbon monoxide in the two atmospheres illustrates this challenge. Interior models examine how different blends of rock and ice can match the available observations (Astronomy & Astrophysics, December 2025).
Why this matters for the 2040s
The stakes go beyond taxonomy. The question goes to the basic nature of two distant planets and to how they formed. It also affects how scientists plan to explore them.
Universe Today reported that a mission named Uranus Orbiter and Probe is currently being developed, with a scheduled arrival at Uranus sometime in the 2040s. That leaves time to refine what researchers expect to find. Voyager 2 flew past Uranus in 1986 and Neptune in 1989, giving scientists their only close spacecraft views of either planet, while more recently, observations of Uranus’ atmosphere have mapped parts of its upper layers.
The modeling work is, for now, the argument is theoretical. Confirmation that these planets contain a solid, rocky portion could come only from a spacecraft equipped with instruments able to sample their atmospheres.