“I can’t see any creative workers leaving their colleagues behind,” said Claire Pullen, chief executive of the Australian Writers’ Guild, responding on Thursday to a report that musicians might get special treatment while artificial intelligence companies scrape everyone else’s work.
Australia’s music industry has rejected a reported government proposal that would exempt musicians from AI training schemes, declaring it will not accept a carveout that abandons writers, filmmakers and the rest of the creative sector. The Australian Financial Review reported the permit idea on Thursday, the Guardian reported, under which AI companies would buy permits to train on Australian content — with music potentially exempted.
The key detail: the people the carveout was supposed to protect don’t want it. Annabelle Herd, chief executive of the Australian Recording Industry Association (Aria), said she learned of the proposal on Thursday but the industry’s position has not moved.
“Had we been consulted, we would have advised this scheme is unnecessary, unworkable and designed to suit the commercial interests of AI companies, not protect creators,” said Annabelle Herd, who told Guardian Australia that “our position is unchanged: we stand with the rest of the creative and media industries.”
Music industry rejects AI training permit scheme
- A permit scheme letting AI firms train on Australian content was reported on Thursday, with music possibly exempted — and the music industry says no.
- Aria, the Australian Writers’ Guild and the Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance all rejected the idea; independent senator David Pocock called it a “divide and conquer strategy”.
- The Albanese government would not comment, but senior ministers including industry minister Tim Ayres and acting prime minister Richard Marles have this week said the copyright status quo is failing creators.
A creative sector that refuses to split
The united front is the story here. This week the creative community launched a major AI campaign, and both Herd and Pullen confirmed the sectors would stay aligned against any scheme that picks them off one by one.
UKPulse noted the strongest language came from Aria’s chief executive, who described the reported scheme as “unnecessary, unworkable and designed to suit the commercial interests of AI companies, not protect creators” — words that leave little room for negotiation.

And there is a practical headache underneath the politics. Both Herd and Pullen questioned how such a scheme would even work technically: a film or television show bundles music, video and screenwriting into one copyrighted whole. If only one element is exempted from AI scraping, what happens to the rest? The Guardian carried Pullen’s verdict on the mechanics — “this just seems like such a convoluted path”.
But the real friction, she argued, is that tech companies have never come to the table. “AI companies have had an open invitation to sit down and negotiate for years,” Pullen told the Guardian. “We have been working with government to come up with a model since 2024. We’ve come up with solutions and tech has steadfastly refused to even talk.”
What big tech has actually asked for
The reported permit idea did not appear from nowhere. It tracks what the AI companies themselves have proposed, per the Guardian’s reporting: Anthropic has suggested a model of “conditional approval”, in which firms could scrape content unless a rightsholder objected, and OpenAI told a parliamentary committee it would “potentially” support paying into a fund for creators.
Read those side by side and the shape of the lobbying is clear — an opt-out rather than opt-in system, with money pooled rather than paid per licence.
| Proposal | Who backs it | How it treats copyright |
|---|---|---|
| Permits bought to train on Australian content | Reported under consideration by government (per the Australian Financial Review) | AI firms may train with a permit; music possibly exempted |
| “Conditional approval” to scrape | Anthropic | Training allowed unless a rightsholder objects |
| Payments into a creator fund | OpenAI, told a parliamentary committee | “Potentially” supported as an alternative to individual licensing |
| Commercial deals with artists | Aria, Writers’ Guild, Albanese government’s stated position | Consent and payment before use |
An anonymous industry source told the Guardian they would welcome the permit plan — the only voice quoted in the reporting that does. Meanwhile the Guardian noted it could not independently verify the proposal’s details, and some within the creative sector told the outlet they had heard nothing of it and doubted government would seriously entertain it.
Canberra’s mixed signals
The government itself has stayed quiet on the specific report. Yet the timing is telling: within days, senior ministers have sharpened their rhetoric about copyright law in the AI age.
On Tuesday the industry minister, Tim Ayres, said “the status quo is no good” for creative workers — a line repeated by acting prime minister Richard Marles on Thursday, who told News24: “People are being ripped off”.
The attorney general, Michelle Rowland, went further through a spokesperson: “Right now, the work of Australian creatives is being used without their consent or payment”.
So which way is Canberra actually leaning? Even parliamentarians are asking. Pocock told the Guardian it is “hard to know what [Labor] are actually doing at the moment” — the joint select committee has not yet delivered its report, and “we’re hearing all sorts of whispers about what the government is planning”.
Across the aisle, one voice
On this, the opposition and the Greens agree. The shadow attorney general, Michaelia Cash, said the proposal would “divide the rightsholders”, adding: “This ham-fisted tactic should be strongly resisted. Everyone who owns property should have the same right for it not to be stolen.”
The Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young warned against bending to big tech’s demands at all.
“Australia will become known as the Cayman Islands for AI if we allow this loophole to happen,” said Hanson-Young, who also told News24 to stand up to them.”
Where this goes next
The union representing writers and creatives, the Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance, said it would be “alarmed” at the reported proposal and demanded the protections promised by Albanese “must apply to all creative sectors”. That is the line in the sand — and the music industry just drew it louder.
The outstanding questions are the ones the reporting cannot yet answer: whether the proposal is real policy or trial ballooning, and what the joint select committee will recommend when its report finally lands.
Pocock, a former Wallabies flanker born in South Africa in 1988 and raised in Zimbabwe, moved to Australia as a teenager after his family emigrated in 2002. He won the John Eales Medal in 2010 and captained the Wallabies during the 2012 test series, before retiring to work as a conservationist and social justice advocate.
Elected to the Senate in 2022 as an independent for the Australian Capital Territory, he became the first independent to represent the ACT in the Senate since the territory gained representation in 1975, defeating Liberal incumbent Zed Seselja.
What is set: the joint select committee’s report to government is still pending, and both sides of Parliament, the crossbench, the unions and the creative industries have, for once, lined up against the same piece of paper. Sarah Hanson-Young urged people to stand up to big tech.