Berlinger Calls New Film ‘Fun Little Shakespearean Tale of Ego, Greed

Documentarian Joe Berlinger describes his new Netflix film Primetime Preacher$ as “a fun little Shakespearean tale of ego, greed and ambition”, a clash among three men who built a televangelism empire that reshaped American politics.

The documentary examines the rise and fall of Jerry Falwell, Jimmy Swaggart and Jim Bakker — the central figures of the 1980s televangelist boom whose scandals Berlinger argues birthed the modern religious right.

From True Crime to Televangelism

In the early 1970s, roughly a quarter of U.S. adults identified as evangelical Christians. The movement encouraged the faithful to tithe generously not only to God’s work but also to the ministers chosen to carry it out, according to The Guardian.

Three Rivals, One Era

The 114-minute film anchors its narrative on Jim and Tammy Faye Bakker, whose Praise the Lord (PTL) Club and Heritage USA theme park became symbols of consumer Christianity’s excess.

Berlinger Calls New Film 'Fun Little Shakespearean Tale of Ego, Greed
Photo: Yahoo

Swaggart, a Louisiana preacher who built his following on sermons condemning sin, took deep offense at Bakker’s PTL. He disparaged Bakker as a false prophet leading a double life, according to The Guardian. The rivalry turned destructive: Swaggart raised concerns with Assemblies of God officials about Bakker and church secretary Jessica Hahn, triggering the exposure of a $265,000 hush-money payment that led to Bakker’s downfall, according to Yahoo Entertainment.

Bakker had told an associate, “If he gets Gorman, he’ll get me”, referring to fellow televangelist Marvin Gorman, whom Swaggart had helped expose. The prediction proved accurate. In March 1987, Bakker stepped down as the story broke; PTL filed for bankruptcy later that year. Bakker was convicted on 24 felony counts of fraud and conspiracy in 1989 and sentenced to 45 years, though released in 1994, according to Yahoo Entertainment and The New York Times.

Swaggart’s reckoning followed in February 1988, when a private investigator hired by Gorman produced photographs linking Swaggart to a woman at a New Orleans motel. Swaggart wept before his congregation in a televised confession, declaring “I have sinned”, and was later stripped of his Assemblies of God credentials, Yahoo Entertainment reported.

The Telegraph Details Financial Machinery Behind Heritage USA

The Telegraph detailed the financial machinery: Bakker raised $30 million in five days at one point, funding Heritage USA, a 2,300-acre Christian theme park in South Carolina with swimming pools, tennis courts and an amphitheater that drew six million visitors a year.

By 1984, Bakker sold $1,000 “lifetime partnerships” promising three nights annually for life — selling far more than rooms could ever accommodate. The park needed $1 million a week to service running costs, The Telegraph reported.

Berlinger Calls New Film 'Fun Little Shakespearean Tale of Ego, Greed
Photo: The Telegraph

The Charlotte Observer’s reporting uncovered the 1984 payment to Hahn, a 21-year-old church secretary who alleged rape in a Florida hotel. Bakker admitted to sex but claimed it was consensual and admitted to the payment. In March 1987, with the story about to break, Bakker declared repentance, resigned and handed PTL to Falwell, believing it temporary, The Telegraph reported.

Political Legacy and a Timely Release

The documentary traces how trouble beyond the pulpit drove a broader political conversion, helping elect Republican presidents from Reagan onward. Trump’s standing with evangelicals was shaky until a timely blessing from Jerry Falwell Jr., who extends the movement’s legacy of scandal and appears in the film invoking his father.

Before his death in 2007, Falwell Sr. declared the scandals had “strengthened broadcast evangelism and made Christianity stronger, more mature and more committed”, according to The Guardian.

Berlinger Calls New Film 'Fun Little Shakespearean Tale of Ego, Greed
Photo: Biography: Historical and Celebrity Profiles

Primetime Preacher$ arrives just over a month after Bakker’s death on October 5, 2026, at age 86. Swaggart died in July 2025 at 90, Yahoo Entertainment noted. The New York Times called the film an “anti-eulogy” that reads at times like camp and at others like horror in showing the dangerous convergence of religious and political power.

Jerry Falwell, born in 1933, founded the Thomas Road Baptist Church in Lynchburg, Virginia, at age 22 and launched the nationally syndicated “Old-Time Gospel Hour” broadcast the same year. He established Liberty University in 1971 and co-founded the Moral Majority in 1979, a political lobby credited with delivering two-thirds of the white evangelical vote to Ronald Reagan in 1980.

In March 1987, Falwell assumed control of the Bakkers’ PTL ministry and Heritage USA theme park after Bakker’s resignation, a move the film notes Falwell believed would be temporary.

Critical Reception

“People can only use God’s name for so long before something happens”, said Beth Ferguson, who once provided security for the Bakkers, in the film. The Guardian noted only Tammy Faye emerges as something close to a redeemable character, appearing genuinely committed to meeting faith-seekers where they were. Berlinger added: “But people want to believe, you know?”

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Bitcoin Trades at $27,000 Equivalent on Kraken BTC/CAD Pair