Birmingham Court Bans Unauthorised Flags on Street Infrastructure

Birmingham won a court order on Wednesday banning unauthorised flags from lampposts, bridges and other street infrastructure across the city.

The High Court granted Birmingham City Council a temporary injunction on November 18, Amoledo reported. The order names Ryan Bridge, co-founder of the Raise The Colours movement, Ben Cullen, who is also linked to the group, and unnamed people taking part in the flag campaign.

It also allows for the arrest of Bridge and unnamed persons if they breach the ban — a measure the council had sought after thousands of Union Jacks and St George’s crosses appeared on the city’s street furniture.

Judge Emma Kelly made clear the restriction covers flags of any kind when they are fixed to highway structures without permission, The Independent reported. That framing matters: the order is written around where a flag sits, not what it stands for.

Residents keep the right to fly flags on their own property. Jane Baston, the council’s cabinet member for equality, communities and social justice, urged people to display them where permission is in place.

The penalty for contempt of court could be severe. Once a certified order with the ban’s conditions is issued, breaches can bring up to two years in prison, a fine or the seizure of assets, the council said.

The legal fight traces back months. On May 21, the council warned it would remove flags fixed without permission to lampposts and railings. In some neighbourhoods they went straight back up, and residents who objected reported abuse and intimidation, Amoledo reported.

The council justified its court action on three grounds: obstruction on the roads, safety risks, and the repeated re-fixing of flags in the same spots.

The hearings that produced the interim measures took place on September 8 and September 30, and again on November 2. The final order followed on November 18.

Bridge’s defence had argued the injunction was unnecessary. At the September 30 hearing, his barrister Liam Wells invoked Articles 10 and 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights — freedom of expression and freedom of assembly — according to a statement from Fraser Chambers, the barristers’ group.

Wells argued that Bridge wants to express his beliefs through the public display of the national flag, and that an injunction backed by the threat of arrest would stop him and others from voicing lawful political views.

The safety case against the campaign was not abstract. At the hearings, the court heard of a man who broke his leg when a cherry picker failed while flags were being put up, The Independent reported. Allegations of assaults and threats were also raised.

What the order does not do is settle the underlying argument. It is temporary, it binds named individuals and unnamed participants within Birmingham’s administrative boundaries, and it says nothing about the wider dispute over who gets to claim the city’s lampposts.

The next step is already on the calendar. A further hearing on the questions arising from the ruling takes place on Thursday, November 19, at the Birmingham Civil and Family Justice Centre, starting at 10:30 local time.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

South Africa Rescues Five Ancient Baobabs Seized En Route to Georgia