Brooklyn Musician Sues Landlord, Builders Over Fatal Flatbush Collapse After Crack Warnings

A Brooklyn musician filed a lawsuit in Brooklyn Supreme Court alleging that he warned his landlord about visible cracks weeks before a residential building collapse in Flatbush killed eight people.

Dengane Omari Jack, a 48-year-old tenant who lived at 1321 Flatbush Ave. for five years, stated in his complaint that he photographed expanding cracks near the entrance of the property in October, according to reporting by Gothamist and The New York Post. The three-story apartment building subsequently collapsed into an adjacent excavation site at 2625 Bedford Ave. at around 4 p.m. on November 11.

The disaster claimed the lives of eight people, including two children, and injured nearly 20 others. Jack lost his home, along with DJ gear, recording equipment, and an extensive vinyl record collection he valued at $100,000, according to The New York Post.

“I'm grieving for the loss of life, and anyone who is injured,” Jack told The Post Monday.

According to the lawsuit, Jack sent photographs of the damage to his landlord, Olufemi Falade. The complaint alleges that Falade dismissed the warnings, telling the tenant “that the condition was not the landlord’s fault or could not be fixed,” and failed to arrange a timely structural investigation or necessary repairs.

Brooklyn Musician Sues Landlord, Builders Over Fatal Flatbush Collapse After Crack Warnings
Photo: nypost.com

Lawsuit Targets Landlord and Builders

The legal action names Falade, who owns the property through Isolag Realty Corp., alongside several companies and individuals connected to the neighboring development project. These include property owners linked to Robert Fischman and Judy Swimer, general contractor Townhouse Builders, subcontractor Elite Concrete, structural engineer Jieming Wang of LMW Engineering, and special inspection firm RI Consulting Services Inc.

The complaint asserts that construction plans for the adjoining site failed to provide for steel support beams, known as rakers, at the precise section where the building ultimately gave way. A preconstruction report had previously documented the poor condition of the side facade overlooking the construction zone, though the engineering firm that prepared it noted they could not access the interior.

City records show the building had accumulated 98 violations through the Department of Housing Preservation and Development prior to the collapse, including unsafe electrical wiring and inadequate water supply for the sprinkler system.

“Our client obviously sends condolences to the families of all those killed, and best wishes to all those injured,” said Scott Epstein, Jack’s attorney, in a phone interview with Gothamist. “The loss of his residence and the entirety of his worldly possessions has traumatically affected him.”

Investigation and City Response

The New York City Department of Buildings has not yet determined the official cause of the fatal collapse. Following the incident, the agency launched a safety inspection blitz targeting other projects handled by the same firms involved in the Flatbush development.

A Gothamist analysis found that inspectors visited at least 24 sites associated with LMW Engineering and RI Consulting Services, issuing stop-work orders at five of them. City records indicate that demolition work at the Bedford Avenue site had previously been halted in March due to missing safety precautions, after which developers were fined $10,000 for proceeding regardless.

Neither Falade nor representatives for Townhouse Builders, Elite Concrete, LMW Engineering, RI Consulting Services, Fischman, or Swimer responded immediately to requests for comment regarding the lawsuit and the structural failure.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Amazon Early Black Friday Tech Deals: Up to 53% Off Apple, Xiaomi, Beats