“I think we’ve been talking about merger for so long in this state we may be overlooking some of the advantages of other situations,” Linda Gray said.
A newly established committee exploring potential school district mergers across a newly expanded section of central Vermont heard sharply differing views from local residents on Thursday night at Northfield Middle and High School.
The four residents who spoke at the second meeting of the regional study committee delivered messages that boiled down to two contrasting stances: expansion on a grand scale or cautious hesitation. The group brings together school board representatives from Barre, Echo Valley, Montpelier-Roxbury, Paine Mountain, Twinfield, and Washington Central, along with a non-voting member from the Central Vermont Career Center board.
Cynthia Gardner-Morse and Linda Gray, both from Calais, traveled to Northfield to urge the committee to proceed with caution. Gardner-Morse told the panel that existing studies fail to demonstrate that merging school districts actually saves money. She argued that if the goal is to improve student outcomes, the real solution lies in providing better teacher training at the university and college level.
Gray echoed those concerns, expressing skepticism that consolidation discussions adequately value small community schools. As one of five towns in the Washington Central Unified Union School District, Gray warned that long-running merger debates might cause officials to overlook the benefits of smaller learning environments, particularly for vulnerable populations.
“I would hate to see us move to something even worse for our disadvantaged students,” Gray said. “I want us to be cautious in this process.”
Conversely, two residents from the Paine Mountain School District presented a different perspective. Rama Schneider of Williamstown and Jamie Cotton, a parent of two from Northfield, told the committee that the status quo in central Vermont public education is failing and requires systemic overhaul.
Schneider, who previously chaired the committee that recommended the voluntary merger establishing the Paine Mountain district in 2018, argued that it is time to think on a much larger scale.
He circulated a map showing the review area, which now encompasses 15 towns stretching from Worcester to Washington following the recent addition of the two-town Echo Valley Community School District. The territory includes six multi-town school districts, or seven if the Central Vermont Career Center district is included.
Describing it as one man’s perspective, Schneider told the committee that the map outlines a single future district. He suggested the region already possesses the infrastructure necessary to transition almost immediately into two regional high schools, four middle schools, and existing elementary schools.
Cotton, whose children are in the sixth and eighth grades, supported Schneider’s vision. She described recent challenges in finding basic athletic leadership, such as securing a basketball coach for a roster with barely enough participants to form a team. While acknowledging the positive aspects of small schools, Cotton emphasized her desire for stronger educational opportunities.
Survey development and upcoming timeline
Following public comments, the committee elected Dan Morris, chair of the Paine Mountain board, to serve as its chair. Members agreed to operate by consensus before turning their attention to an upcoming regional survey intended to gather data for their work.
After reviewing a draft prepared by facilitator Brad Morgan, the committee authorized Morgan and Morris to finalize the survey for public release. The committee plans to review the survey results when it meets on Dec. 22 at U-32 Middle and High School in East Montpelier.
That gathering will mark the third of the region’s five high schools to host a committee session, following previous meetings at Montpelier High School and Northfield.
Morris informed the committee that the Paine Mountain board intends to ask voters in March to shutter both district high schools—located in Northfield and Williamstown—and tuition older students to other area high schools. Potential destination options under discussion include Spaulding High School in Barre, Montpelier High School, and U-32. Morris noted that any changes would require state approval and voter consent, with a target implementation date of fall 2028.
The proposal stems from the Paine Mountain district’s difficulties in passing a budget over the past three consecutive years, alongside declining enrollment and limited student opportunities.
Fiscal pressures across regional districts
Other districts in the review area face distinct financial and structural challenges. Barre recently passed a school budget on its fourth attempt, marking the second time in four years it required multiple votes, while officials discuss potential structural changes for two pre-K-8 schools located just 2.5 miles apart.
Meanwhile, the Washington Central district received a draft level-service budget earlier in the week that requires more than $1.7 million in reductions to comply with state excess spending thresholds. Tim Duggan, a school director for the Montpelier-Roxbury Public Schools district, noted that while his district remains open-minded about potential mergers, members require clear data demonstrating tangible value before supporting structural changes.
“I don’t think anyone wants to hear a proposal … based on some vague concept of ‘bigger being better,’” Duggan said. “Show me that this makes sense.”
Erin Barry, chair of the Twinfield School Board, noted that high school opportunities remain a persistent concern with growing local momentum. “There are a number of people who are ready for a change,” Barry said.
The Central Vermont Career Center shares its Barre campus with Spaulding High School and enrolls students from that school and other area high schools in career and technical programs. It is represented on the regional study committee by a non-voting board member.
Morgan stated that the immediate next steps involve distributing the survey and establishing an asset-mapping template for regional superintendents. Despite a scheduled reporting deadline next September, Morgan noted that the committee remains ahead of schedule compared to similar initiatives across the state.