Eighty-five percent of surveyed clinicians know that food allergy panels often produce false positives, yet many keep ordering the tests for unvalidated indications such as eczema, hives, and direct family requests, according to research presented at the American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology 2026 Annual Meeting.
The study highlights a distinct disconnect between clinical awareness and daily practice. Broad panels measure immunoglobulin E antibodies to multiple foods simultaneously, frequently flagging sensitization rather than a true clinical allergy. This overtesting can trigger unnecessary dietary restrictions, stress, and financial burdens for patients and families.
“Most of the clinicians we surveyed already knew these tests could lead to false positive results, but many still ordered them despite current guidelines advising against their use,” said Katelyn Wong, MD, allergist-immunologist and senior author of the study, as reported by News-Medical.
Broad blood panels can cause false-positive results
- False-positive results: Broad blood panels often indicate immune system sensitization to a food without a corresponding physical allergic reaction.
- Unnecessary avoidance: Cutting safe foods out of a child’s diet based solely on test numbers can lead to unnecessary dietary restrictions and stress.
- Targeted history: Primary care clinicians should first take a careful clinical history rather than ordering a broad panel.
Clinicians acknowledge high false-positive rates despite uncertainty
To examine why these testing habits persist, researchers contacted 300 clinicians who ordered at least one food allergy panel in 2024 at their institution. A total of 43 clinicians completed the anonymous survey, consisting of 58% physicians and 40% nurse practitioners or physician assistants, primarily from internal medicine and pediatric practices, as detailed by Clinical Lab Products.
While 85% of respondents acknowledged the high false-positive rate, uncertainty remained regarding appropriate testing indications. Respondents identified IgE-mediated food allergy at 38%, urticaria at 29%, and eczema at 14% as appropriate indications for testing. Actual ordering habits closely mirrored these misconceptions.

Training backgrounds also influenced clinical decisions. When evaluating a patient with eczema and a family history of food allergies, 63% of nurse practitioners and physician assistants agreed that a panel was indicated, compared with 30% of physicians, marking a statistically significant difference, according to findings covered by Respiratory Therapy.
| Clinician Group | Agreed Panel Indicated for Eczema & Family History | Recognized False-Positive Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Physicians (MD/DO) | 30% | High (85% total cohort) |
| Nurse Practitioners & Physician Assistants | 63% | High (85% total cohort) |
The heavy burden of unnecessary food avoidance
At a single hospital system, researchers said that more than 1,700 broad food allergy panels were ordered in a single year. These indiscriminate tests can affect families seeking pediatric care.
“False-positive results can lead families to cut out foods that were never actually unsafe, cause unnecessary stress, and add extra costs,” Wong told Newswise.

Pandya said that more research is needed to understand why clinicians continue ordering broad food allergy panels despite their limitations. Flawed data interpretation or gaps in training can foster unneeded evaluations, though the exact drivers behind this trend remain incompletely understood.
Avoid broad food allergy panels to prevent false positives
“Broad, indiscriminate food allergy panels should be avoided because they often produce false-positive results that can lead to unnecessary dietary restrictions and anxiety,” Wong said. Primary care clinicians should first take a careful history. If diagnostic uncertainty remains, sending the patient to a specialist helps confirm whether a legitimate food sensitivity is present.
Next steps for clinician education
Study authors concluded that targeted clinician education may prove helpful to reduce the use of food allergy panels. Further research is needed to understand why clinicians continue ordering broad food allergy panels despite their limitations.
“Primary care clinicians should first take a careful history to discern what symptoms were noted after eating a food,” Wong said.
References
- Annals of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology – ACAAI 2026 Annual Scientific Meeting Abstracts.
- American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology (ACAAI) – Clinical Guidance on Food Allergy Diagnostics.