CNBC Compares Driving vs Flying Costs on Three Major Holiday Routes

Nearly 81.5 million Americans will travel 50 miles or more for Thanksgiving this year, and the cost calculus between driving and flying has shifted sharply since 2023.

Gasoline prices remain roughly 18% above year-ago levels according to AAA data from Nov. 19, while the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported airfare surged 22.4% in September versus the same month last year. CNBC analyzed three of the nation’s busiest domestic corridors using current AAA fuel costs, finding driving wins on the two shortest routes but flying prevails on the longest.

The Bottom Line

  • Los Angeles–San Francisco: Driving costs $155 round-trip in fuel versus $402 for airfare, a 61% savings for drivers.
  • Atlanta–Orlando: Fuel runs $110 round-trip against $430 for flights, a 74% discount for the road.
  • Denver–Phoenix: Adding a $171 hotel stay pushes the driving total to $572 round-trip, while flights average $388, making air travel 32% cheaper.

Short-haul routes favor the road

The Los Angeles to San Francisco corridor spans 381 miles via I-5 North. At California’s Nov. 19 average pump price and the EPA’s 27.2 mpg fleet benchmark, a round trip consumes about $155 in gasoline. The average round-trip ticket is $402. Atlanta to Orlando covers 440 miles on I-75 South; blended Georgia-Florida fuel prices yield a $110 round-trip fuel bill against a $430 average airfare. Neither drive requires an overnight stay, keeping the comparison clean.

Long-haul math flips when lodging enters

Denver to Phoenix stretches 821 miles across Colorado, Utah, and Arizona — a 12.5-hour slog. Unweighted state fuel averages put one-way gas at $115, or $230 round-trip. But the duration almost demands a hotel stop. At the current $171 national average nightly rate, the all-in driving cost hits $572 round-trip. The average flight on this route, the cheapest of the three studied, costs $388 round-trip. Here, the airline’s scale efficiency outweighs the pump.

Hidden costs narrow the gap

Tolls, parking, meals, and vehicle depreciation add to the cost of driving. On the aviation side, checked-bag fees average $35 each way on major carriers unless waived by co-branded credit cards.

The United Explorer Card, for instance, offers a first checked bag free for the cardholder and one companion, saving up to $200 per round-trip. Airport security delays, exacerbated by a recent FAA ground stop, also carry an opportunity cost that does not appear in the fare.

Route Miles Drive Cost (Fuel + Hotel) Avg Round-Trip Airfare Cheaper Mode
Los Angeles – San Francisco 381 $155 $402 Drive
Atlanta – Orlando 440 $110 $430 Drive
Denver – Phoenix 821 $572 $388 Fly

Rewards arbitrage shifts the breakeven

Travel cards alter the ledger. The Chase Sapphire Preferred earns 3X points on gas and EV charging, effectively rebating a significant portion on fuel spend when points are transferred to partners like World of Hyatt or Southwest Airlines (NYSE: LUV).

The Citi Strata Card offers 3X ThankYou points on gas with no annual fee and a 0% introductory APR for 15 months, letting road-trippers finance the trip at zero cost while banking transferable points for future flights. For flyers, the United Explorer Card’s $120 Global Entry/TSA PreCheck credit and two United Club passes per year reduce both monetary and time costs.

AAA projects 90% of holiday travelers will drive, 7% will fly, and 3% will use bus, train, or cruise. The decision, ultimately, remains a function of distance, party size, and whether the traveler values time or liquidity more. The Denver–Phoenix crossover suggests the inflection point sits near 800 miles for a solo traveler — lower if a household shares the fuel bill, higher if checked bags and rental cars await at the destination.

CNBC, relaunched on April 17, 1989, from the Satellite Program Network’s transponder, built its reach by acquiring the bankrupt Financial News Network for $154.3 million in 1991 — a deal that more than doubled its distribution to over 40 million homes and brought anchors like Joe Kernen onto the desk.

The network, headquartered in Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, also broadcasts from the Nasdaq MarketSite in Times Square and the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, a physical presence in the markets it covers.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Lehmann Again Denies Sandpaper Knowledge, Reveals ‘Dark Place’ Fallout