Israel’s flagship Holocaust program sends 25,000 teenagers to Poland each year, even after a 2009 government finding that such trips alone can distort history.
The initiative began in 1988 with roughly 200 participants. By 2009 it ballooned to about 25,000 students each year. That year a Knesset committee heard the Education Ministry acknowledge that school trips exclusively to Poland could create a skewed understanding of the Holocaust. Yet the program’s destination and structure remained unchanged.
A 2011 State Comptroller report was scathing. It criticized Poland as the sole location, the program’s high cost, unequal access, and the lack of meaningful evaluation.
“Since the trips began, the Education Ministry has never bothered to check matters such as their effect on participants, their added value, the extent to which they achieve their goals, whether they alter teens' stances, or the reasons many teens abstain from them,” State Comptroller Micha Lindenstrauss wrote in his report.
A 2007 study by the National Authority for Measurement and Evaluation in Education (RAMA) showed overwhelmingly positive results. Published in 2011, it found 87% of participants reported a stronger connection to Jewish history. About 92% said they gained a better understanding of Israel’s significance for the Jewish people, while 85% reported feeling proud to be Israeli.
However, a 2023 Knesset Research and Information Center review said that, to its knowledge, the Education Ministry had not commissioned a new study on the trips’ effectiveness since that 2011 report.
Expense has consistently been a major hurdle. In 2009 the program cost approximately NIS 162 million. Parents covered around NIS 147 million of that total—91%. The Education Ministry’s direct contribution was just NIS 15 million.
The State Comptroller’s report revealed that about two-thirds of delegations came from the wealthiest third of Israeli schools. A 2012 study confirmed the disparity, finding that 61% of students who did not participate cited cost as the primary reason. The ministry responded with a subsidy program for low-income families that year, allocating more than NIS 50 million.
The program’s future has repeatedly been jeopardized by diplomatic tensions. In 2022 Israel suspended trips to Poland over disputes about security arrangements and program content. This followed years of friction, including disagreements over Polish legislation on historical responsibility and property claims.
An interministerial committee led by Dr. Eli Shish examined seven alternative countries: Austria, Germany, Hungary, Greece, Latvia, Lithuania, and the Czech Republic. The committee identified Germany, Hungary, and Lithuania as potentially suitable options, though each had significant limitations. The final recommendation was to continue trips to Poland wherever possible, using other destinations primarily as a backup.
“Imagine: a guide studies for an entire year, and then you tell him: now you're going to lead tours in Germany. You need retraining. It's very, very complicated,” Richler-Friedman explained.
The 2011 report by State Comptroller Micha Lindenstrauss (2005–2012), produced by the office’s inspection units for ministries, detailed the Education Ministry’s failure to evaluate the trips’ impact or cost-effectiveness. However, the State Comptroller lacks statutory enforcement authority; it relies on the Knesset to impose sanctions on errant bodies and may recommend that the State Audit Committee appoint a special commission of inquiry.
In March 2023 Israel and Poland agreed to resume the program. The deal resolved security concerns and expanded the historical narrative to include a broader view of Polish history. However, a list of historical sites proposed by the Polish side sparked controversy. The Education Ministry rejected claims that the agreement forced students to visit locations that distorted the historical record.