COP31 Talks Deadlocked Over Draft Deal as EU Demands ‘Significant Change

“Lean in and move faster.” With those words, delegates at the COP31 climate summit in Antalya were urged on Tuesday to accelerate negotiations that remain deadlocked over an 18-page draft deal published by co-host Australia.

The draft — covering fossil fuel phaseout, finance and climate science — needs “significant change,” according to the European Union’s climate chief.

The warning came as ministers arrived for the high-level segment after a first week dominated by technical talks. The summit’s aim is the “age of electricity,” anchored in a pledge to raise electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35% by 2035 — from just over a fifth today. But that target, and the deal itself, are contested.

Here is why that matters. Whatever comes out of Antalya this week will guide how tens of billions in climate finance flow, how quickly power grids shift from oil and gas to wires and batteries, and whether the world’s carbon-cutting architecture holds together through the decade.

A “shopping list” in an 18-page draft

Negotiators warned on Tuesday that the sprawling draft “cover decision” sets the stage for tough bargaining before the UN talks end later this week. It bundles demands — a fossil fuel phaseout, a defence of climate science, and long-running fights over finance — into one text.

Wopke Hoekstra, EU Commissioner for Climate, Net Zero and Clean Growth, reaffirms the bloc’s climate commitments
Photo: TRT World

Wopke Hoekstra, the EU Commissioner for Climate, Net Zero and Clean Growth, told reporters the draft had “many of the characteristics of a shopping list” that reopens old issues. “I think the cover decision does not go in the right direction and needs significant change,” he said.

Some European officials described the text as a “Christmas wish list” — trying to please everyone, pleasing no one. Australian Climate Minister Chris Bowen, steering the negotiations, conceded on Monday that it contained elements “that not all parties agree on,” promising “at least one more draft” before the week ends.

Arab Group and Russia reject draft climate text

The resistance is organised. The Arab Group and the Russian Federation rejected the draft text, opposing language that targets specific energy sources, introduces top-down sectoral targets and sets the 35% electrification goal. The Like-Minded Developing Countries said the draft crosses their red lines on the same point.

Saudi Arabia sits at the centre of a second fight: the timeline for the UN climate science panel’s next reports. Dozens of European, African and Pacific nations want the IPCC’s next assessment published before a global stocktake at COP33 in 2028, but Saudi Arabia and India are pushing for the “seventh assessment report” to slip to 2029.

The science lobby is combative. “We have to defend science. We have to defend the scientists,” Laurence Tubiana, CEO of the European Climate Foundation and an architect of the Paris Agreement, told a packed plenary on Monday. Mary Robinson, former President of Ireland, said “the world cannot afford to undermine or lose the IPCC.”

COP31 Talks Deadlocked Over Draft Deal as EU Demands 'Significant Change
Photo: WTVB

Fossil fuel lobbyists flood COP31 talks

More than 100 corporations and industry groups tied to fossil fuel interests — including ExxonMobil and TotalEnergies — have sent delegations to COP31. More than 1,700 fossil fuel lobbyists attended the 2024 talks in Azerbaijan, and more than 1,600 attended the COP30 talks in Brazil.

Academics describe the lobbying method as “discourses of delay.” The pattern is two-pronged, researchers have found.

The electricity bet, in numbers

Turkey’s presidency hopes electrification becomes the centrepiece of the final deal. More than 30 countries have joined the voluntary pledge, which would cut around 4.1 billion metric tons of carbon emissions a year even without prioritising clean power, roughly 7% of current global emissions. Double that, says the tracker Climate TRACE, if new generation is renewable.

COP31 ministers push for climate deal ahead of deadline — TRT World
Metric Figure
Electricity’s share of final energy today Just over 20%
Pledge target by 2035 35%
EU’s own indicative target by 2040 46%
Emissions cut if pledge met, any power ~4.1 bn tonnes/yr (7% of global)

But there is a catch. Climate Analytics warned that without specifying renewable sources, the pledge could leave gas use for power rising, cutting global energy-related CO2 emissions only about 20–25% between 2025 and 2035. OPEC General Haitham Al Ghais pushed back publicly, noting that the infrastructure moving electrical equipment is itself “overwhelmingly dominated by petroleum-powered transportation,” in a note published by OPEC on November 10.

Where the money argument stands

Hoekstra framed the EU’s case bluntly: “there will be no money” in the world enough to address the climate crisis’s damage without action, and the EU — the world’s largest donor — stands by its commitments. He pointed to last summer across Europe as “a sobering reminder” of what lies ahead, and urged faster electrification: “The more, the better. The quicker, the better. The cleaner, the better.”

COP31 Talks Deadlocked Over Draft Deal as EU Demands 'Significant Change
Photo: International Labour Organization

The G77 bloc of 134 countries, for its part, wants financial support attached to any new targets. The NCQG mandate is anchored in Article 9.3 of the Paris Agreement — continuing a $100 billion mobilisation goal with no quantified floor for developed countries’ public provision — while vulnerable countries press for clear scope and delivery timelines.

Outside the negotiating halls, a Just Transition Pavilion opened at COP31, backed by the European Commission and organised with the International Labour Organization. Moustapha Gueye, Director of the ILO Policy Hub, said the challenge “now is to translate this growing recognition into implementation.”

What happens next is the hardest part. Bowen has promised at least one more draft before the week ends, ministers take the podium this week, and the fossil fuel phaseout fight looms.

As Michael Joseph, the environment minister of Antigua and Barbuda, put it: “We would love to see a commitment that calls for the phasing out of fossil fuels” — though consensus on that, he admitted, “might be very, very difficult.”

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Why There’s No New Law & Order & SVU Episode Tonight on November 19