Scoperto più alto se ripari l’auto dal carrozziere di fiducia: come contestarlo, dal reclamo all…
Insurance policy clauses imposing higher deductibles for repairing vehicles outside network workshops are not automatically valid, following a ruling by the Corte di Cassazione deposited on April 23, 2026, which mandates case-by-case judicial review rather than a blanket ban, Motori.money.it reported.
Assessing Deductible Penalties
Policyholders facing increased financial penalties when selecting independent repair shops can challenge these clauses through formal complaint procedures and arbitration. The disputed terms typically appear within accessory coverages such as Kasko, theft, fire, atmospheric events, and vandalism policies, establishing dual percentage rates for repairs inside versus outside approved networks.
Motori.money.it illustrated the mechanism using percentages from the Supreme Court case, where policies enforced a 15% charge for network repairs against a 20% charge for non-network options. On a 3,000 euro damage claim, the insured party pays 450 euro at a partner shop compared to 600 euro elsewhere, generating an additional 150 euro out-of-pocket expense.
Judicial Scrutiny on Vandalism and Direct Compensation
The Supreme Court reviewed a vandalism guarantee dispute involving Covea Fleet, subsequently merged into Mma Iard, where the lower court ruling was annulled and referred back to the Milan Court of Appeal in a different composition, according to Money. Under articles 33-36 of the Consumer Code, the court must ascertain whether the clause was genuinely negotiated or unilaterally imposed by the insurance provider using pre-printed forms.
“un paradosso che porta le compagnie a pagare in modo diverso lo stesso danno a seconda di chi lo ripara,” said Davide Galli, presidente di Federcarrozzieri, speaking to Open.
The legal framework requires insurance companies to prove a genuine negotiation occurred rather than relying on standard module templates. According to Motori.money.it, this legal principle applies exclusively to individual private consumers rather than corporate fleets and business entities.
Formal Complaint and Dispute Resolution Channels
Policyholders seeking recourse must initiate a written complaint directly with the insurance company’s designated claims office, which is legally required to respond within 45 days. If the insurance provider fails to respond or delivers an unsatisfactory resolution, claimants can escalate the dispute to the Istituto per la vigilanza sulle assicurazioni using the official submission protocol.
Since January 15, 2026, claimants have gained access to the Arbitro Assicurativo, an independent body supported by the regulatory authority governed by a five-member panel. Submissions to the arbitration panel require prior completion of the insurer complaint process, cost 20 euro which is refunded if successful, and are evaluated solely through documentation within a 180-day window that permits a 90-day extension for complex proceedings.
The Corte di Cassazione, Italy’s highest court of appeal seated in Rome’s Palace of Justice, issued the April 2026 ruling that requires judges to scrutinize whether higher deductibles for non-network repairs were genuinely negotiated or unilaterally imposed.
Established in 1865 under the former Civil Code and reorganized by royal decree in 1941, the court ensures uniform legal interpretation across civil and criminal divisions, with panels of five or nine judges delivering final judgments that harmonize jurisprudence nationwide without creating binding precedent.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.