“It looks like they had decided who they wanted to blame from the very beginning.” David Warner’s accusation, posted on Instagram on Saturday and reported by The Times of India, landed hours before Cricket Australia tried to end the Sandpapergate war — announcing an independent forum in Hobart on Wednesday that will hear recollections of the 2018 ball-tampering scandal but impose no new sanctions.
Usman Khawaja and Warner, the two men whose public statements blew the case open again, both questioned the forum within hours of its creation. Khawaja told Fox Sports he feared testimony would simply disappear.
“I could go in there and say something, but then the board can decide that they’re not going to release that, and I just feel like then we just go in a circle again,” he said, Sky Sports reported.
Warner, seated beside Khawaja on a punditry panel for Wednesday’s third ODI between Australia and England in Hobart, wanted more than a listening exercise. “I would have liked an open, independent inquiry, and the people that were there at the time actually can come forward and speak, because we have no idea about what’s happened behind closed doors,” he told Sky Sports.
Another earthquake in Australian cricket with the Bancroft revelations. They have no option now but to address the issue directly. A forum to express thoughts with no further action is now untenable. This is one of Australian cricket's biggest moments and just requires them to do…
The stakes are reputational rather than competitive — no series points, no selections, no captaincy hangs on this — but the fallout has consumed an Australian summer that was meant to be about the England white-ball tour. Instead, the third ODI was played with the governing body’s interim chair and chief executive holding a press conference at Bellerive Oval barely an hour before the first ball.
Forum leaves player markets untouched but threatens sponsor ties
- No playing consequences flow from the forum: CA has ruled out new punishments, so availability and captaincy markets for the remaining England ODIs and T20Is are untouched.
- Front-office exposure is the real risk — sponsor and broadcast partners will watch whether the forum produces a public account or a confidential file, per Politico’s reporting on its terms.
- Narrative risk sits with current captain Pat Cummins and the bowlers group, whose collective 2021 statement Cameron Bancroft described in his testimony to The West Australian as “deeply painful.”
Khawaja’s book reopened the file
The trigger was Sabr, Khawaja’s autobiography published last week, per Cricinfo. In it, the veteran batter alleged sandpaper was used on the ball in the Port Elizabeth Test before the Cape Town incident, that the entire squad knew what was happening, and that he was never interviewed in the original investigation despite sitting next to Cameron Bancroft in the dressing room during the Cape Town Test.
Warner and reserve seamer Chadd Sayers backed the account. Sayers, per Cricinfo, confirmed he was aware of sandpaper use in Port Elizabeth and that he carried the sandpaper off the field after Bancroft used it. Bancroft then went further, telling The West Australian in a 4,000-word testimony that “in 2018 not the entire truth was told” and that “it was not just the three of us.”
But the tape tells a different story from the current leadership. Cummins, in a 68-minute press conference in Sydney last Friday, called the claims “100% wrong” and “utter nonsense,” Cricinfo reported. Mitchell Starc denied any knowledge of sandpaper use earlier in the week.
Warner escalated on Saturday with the accusation that CA never interviewed Josh Hazlewood, Starc or Nathan Lyon in its 2018 investigation. “If that’s correct, then how can CA push the idea that the bowlers didn’t know?” he wrote, in the post reported by The Times of India, calling it a “shoddy investigation” that “stinks of a cover up.”
A forum built to avoid verdicts
Interim chair David Boon and chief executive Todd Greenberg announced the forum in Hobart on Wednesday morning, an hour before the third ODI. “This forum is not about relitigating the past. It is about creating an opportunity for those who wish to be heard to tell their stories in a respectful environment, and for our sport to listen,” Boon said.
The design is the controversy. Politico reported that participation is voluntary, testimony is confidential and the board decides what the public gets to hear — the exact structure Khawaja flagged when he said the process could “just go in a circle again.”
Former deputy prime minister Michael McCormack told Sky News’ Kieran Gilbert, per Politico: “It’s done. Move on.” Former prime minister Malcolm Turnbull pressed the other way, asking why Khawaja did not speak up at the time.
The original sanctions, eight years on, remain the fixed point of the dispute:

| Player | 2018 sanction | Role in scandal |
|---|---|---|
| Steve Smith | One-year ban, stripped of captaincy | Then captain; sanctioned after short investigation |
| David Warner | One-year ban | Then vice-captain; sanctioned after short investigation |
| Cameron Bancroft | Nine-month ban | Caught with sandpaper in Cape Town Test |
No other player or coach was punished. That asymmetry — three men sanctioned after what the BBC described as a short investigation, versus claims now from four sources that knowledge ran through the squad — is what the forum exists to defuse without reopening it.
Not everyone is unhappy. Darren Lehmann, Australia’s head coach in 2018, backed the forum. “I actually like it, I do. I think we’ve done the best of a terrible situation. For me, it’s the light at the end of the tunnel,” he said.
Gideon Haigh & I responding to Bancrofts statement shortly after it dropped https://t.co/SJWc0pusSg
Healy’s counterblast
Ian Healy turned the argument on the accusers on Wednesday, telling SEN radio that those who stayed silent are now “guilty whistleblowers.” “They didn’t come forward when it was saveable, now there’s a massive stain on cricket and they’ll be known as liars forever,” he said.
“This was not Uzzy’s story to tell, he wasn’t involved and didn’t do anything. Why write about that? He should have done it the day after the occurrence. It’s Davey’s book to write,” Healy said on SEN.
The schedule gives the dispute a live backdrop. England won the second ODI in Adelaide by 135 runs after Australia took the opener in Perth by seven wickets; the third ODI was played in Hobart on Wednesday, with the T20I series starting in Melbourne on Saturday, November 21. Warner and Khawaja will be on air for much of it.
What happens next is CA’s move: the board, having declined to reopen its investigation, will now decide who is invited to speak, what is said and — as Khawaja warned — what the public ever gets to hear.