Only eight of the eleven players who took the field in the 2018 Cape Town Test were ever questioned by the original ball-tampering investigation, Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg confirmed this week.
Eight years on, CA has announced an independent forum for players and staff to share their accounts — and the fallout is still widening.
The announcement came after an emergency board meeting, declared in Hobart ahead of the third ODI between Australia and England by chair David Boon and Greenberg, Mangalam reported.
The forum will be chaired by a retired judge or King’s Counsel to be appointed in the coming days, and it will be entirely confidential: no reopening of the original investigation, no new sanctions, no publication of findings unless the board later decides otherwise.
What forced CA’s hand was a book. Usman Khawaja’s autobiography Sabar aired allegations last week that sandpaper was also used on the ball during the Port Elizabeth Test, not just at Newlands, and that everyone in the 2018 dressing room knew what was happening.
Former opener Cameron Bancroft followed with a column in The West Australian making the same collective-knowledge claim, adding that he was made a scapegoat once television cameras caught him.
I'm training at Cricket Central tomorrow morning before the Blues play in the Shield match. Happy to speak with any and all media about the events of this week at 9.30 am. I've taken some time to try and better understand the long list and full extent of Uzzy’s allegations so I…
“My cricket career was destroyed. I have not played for my country since the period when Justin Langer was coach in 2019,” Bancroft wrote in the column. He also said Pat Cummins’ comments at a press conference last week left him feeling “cheated and alone” — Bancroft, 33, sat next to Cummins in that Cape Town dressing room, yet Khawaja revealed he was never interviewed in the first inquiry.
The measurable disparity is stark. Three men carried the punishment; eight of eleven were never even asked. Here is what the record shows:

| Player | Role in 2018 | Sanction |
|---|---|---|
| Steve Smith | Captain | 12-month ban |
| David Warner | Vice-captain | 12-month ban |
But the tape tells a different story than the official one. Bancroft, according to his column, has now detailed how the plan evolved: David Warner handled the ball most often in pursuit of reverse swing during that South Africa tour, the mood hardened after the first-Test win in Durban, and conversations about using sandpaper at Port Elizabeth involved head coach Darren Lehmann and bowling coach David Sacker.
Steve Smith wanted to stay away from the plan, Bancroft wrote. And after the Cape Town exposure, staff instructed him not to admit the object was sandpaper, he claims.
Warner, who served a 12-month ban, backs Khawaja — but wants more than a private forum, according to Asianet News Malayalam. Warner called for an open public inquiry, questioning what Cricket Australia has privately discussed with former staff and whether witnesses to the 2018 events will ever be heard openly.
“I want an open and independent inquiry where those who were there can come forward and speak,” Warner said. “We do not know what Cricket Australia and former staff have privately discussed. That is very important too.”
Khawaja, for his part, is wary of a closed room. Reacting to the announcement, he warned that if the board releases only what it likes from the eventual report, nothing is really resolved. Asked on ABC’s 7:30 program on Wednesday whether Australian bowlers had a role in the 2018 tampering, Khawaja declined to speculate beyond the book, pointing instead to former seamer Chadd Sayers’ corroboration.
Sayers’ account is the most damaging new detail. The pacer, part of the 2018 South Africa touring squad, confirmed he knew sandpaper was used at Port Elizabeth and said he was the one who carried the sandpaper out of the ground after Bancroft used it, per Mangalam. He also confirmed a post-incident team meeting in the Cape Town dressing room in which discussion turned to collective responsibility.

On the other side of the ledger, denials. Cummins has dismissed the book’s allegations. Greenberg framed the episode as a wound the sport still feels: “When we hear the conflicting revelations about what happened in Cape Town in 2018, cricket as a sport is hurting right now. This is not good for anyone.”
The boardroom stakes are real. This is not simply reputational housekeeping — it is a governance test for a CA regime that built its legitimacy on the Ethics Center review commissioned after 2018, which produced 42 recommendations, 36 of which Greenberg says were implemented.
That culture reset under Tim Paine, Langer and now Cummins and Andrew McDonald is precisely what CA says the new allegations threaten to trivialize. Cummins put it bluntly: Khawaja “has every right to tell his story and I’m happy about that. But we should take responsibility for what we say and do.”
Cummins himself was due to face the media at Cricket Central on Friday at 9:30am, before a Shield match, after saying on X on November 11 that he needed time to understand the full extent of Khawaja’s allegations before responding. Khawaja, meanwhile, canceled his book tour.
What happens next is procedural but consequential: a chair will be named, participation is voluntary for anyone from the 2018 squad, and the board decides later how much of the record becomes public. The gap the forum must close is the same one that opened in 2018 — three men punished, eleven in the room, and only a fraction of them ever asked to account for it.

“Preserving an incomplete story does more harm than the truth,” Bancroft wrote. “I’m at that stage now.”
Fantasy & Market Impact
- Bancroft’s public willingness to appear before the forum keeps his name in Sheffield Shield conversion conversations, though he has not played for Australia since 2019 under Langer — national recall futures remain frozen.
- Cummins’ Friday media availability, coming days after Test commitments, carries leadership-odds implications; any misstep on Khawaja’s claims could reopen debate over the captaincy succession picture.
- Warner’s push for a public inquiry, if it gains traction, extends an off-field news cycle that has already disrupted merchandise-adjacent commercial timing around Australia’s current ODI series against England.
Disclaimer: The fantasy and market insights provided are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute financial or betting advice.