Crisis Group Warns UN: Rushed South Sudan Elections Risk “Decisive Final Blow” to Peace Deal

South Sudan faces a “decisive final blow” to its 2018 peace agreement if planned elections proceed on 22 December without political consensus, the International Crisis Group warned the UN Security Council on Monday, as fighting between government forces and opposition-aligned militias escalates across the north.

Murithi Mutiga, Crisis Group’s Africa Programme Director, told the Council that President Salva Kiir’s administration has systematically dismantled the power-sharing deal struck with former First Vice President Riek Machar, placing Machar under house arrest in March 2025, purging opposition lawmakers mid-year, and dissolving the unity government in September in favour of a loyalist caretaker cabinet.

“The conditions for credible polls are not currently in place,” Mutiga said. “Rushed elections could be a decisive final blow to the 2018 framework and would open the door to a return to sustained large-scale violence.”

The briefing came as African Union High Representative Jakaya Kikwete, appointed special envoy for the Horn of Africa and the Red Sea in March, reported that South Sudan’s National Elections Commission has received only $21 million of the $276 million it requested, with 42 days remaining before the scheduled vote. Kikwete, briefing the Council after visits to Juba in April and June, said every interlocutor — including government ministers, opposition leaders, civil society, and regional heads of state — acknowledged a deepening political and security crisis.

“All admitted that there is a problem,” Kikwete told the Council, according to the UN transcript. “I met nobody who denied that there was no problem.”

The SPLM-IO, Machar’s party, has accused Kiir of unilaterally removing its officials from government and replacing them with loyalists, while denouncing Machar’s treason trial as politically motivated. Juba has so far denied Kikwete and other envoys access to Machar, blocking mediation efforts aimed at securing a cessation of hostilities.

Fighting has surged since late December 2025, when the Sudan People’s Liberation Army-In Opposition (SPLA-IO), fighting alongside military defectors and armed Nuer youth, engaged national forces across northern Jonglei and eastern Upper Nile states. With the regular army unpaid and overstretched — oil revenues have collapsed after Sudan’s civil war severed export routes — Juba has relied on allied ethnic auxiliaries conducting “scorched-earth tactics, mass displacement, and deliberate attacks on civilians,” Mutiga said.

The humanitarian toll is severe.

Roughly 10 million people need urgent aid, 7.8 million face acute hunger, and sexual violence is widespread, according to Crisis Group. Extreme flooding in 2025 displaced over 375,000 people; prolonged drought in 2026 has affected nearly four million and devastated crops and livestock. More than 1.3 million displaced persons and returnees have crossed from Sudan, exhausting communal resources and cutting off diaspora remittances.

Anita Kiki Gbeho, the Secretary-General’s Special Representative and head of UNMISS, warned that key concerns persist over security arrangements, logistics, and the elections commission’s capacity to deliver a vote within an “extremely compressed timeframe.” She stressed that elections “cannot substitute for political dialogue, confidence-building and continued implementation of the Peace Agreement.”

Crisis Group laid out five recommendations: a unified diplomatic push behind Kikwete and the AU’s C5 committee (chaired by South Africa); immediate access for envoys to Machar to negotiate a ceasefire and the dropping of charges; pressure on Kiir to delay elections until conditions are credible; a “mobile, flexible, and robust” UNMISS posture with temporary operating bases along conflict flashpoints and supply lines; and vigorous Council backing for the mission’s climate-security and gender mandates.

Kikwete urged the Council and AU to work in lockstep. “If they are not conducted well, the crisis will begin again immediately,” he said of the elections.

The AU’s Ad Hoc High-Level Committee on South Sudan (C5) — comprising South Africa, Nigeria, Rwanda, Algeria, and Chad — was established in 2014 after the 2013 outbreak of civil war between Kiir and Machar’s forces.

Kikwete said regional leaders — Uganda’s Yoweri Museveni, Kenya’s William Ruto, and Ethiopia’s Abiy Ahmed — share a common border and “are regularly involved in the issues in South Sudan.”

Whether the 22 December vote proceeds or not, Mutiga said, mediators must assemble an inclusive political dialogue among South Sudanese factions to chart a political future. “The people of South Sudan have endured decades of compounding tragedy,” he told the Council. “They are entitled to a future founded on genuine peace, physical security, and sustainable self-reliance.”

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Jonathan Rinderknecht Convicted of Arson in Deadly Palisades Fire