UConn spent a week scouting Arizona forward RJ Godfrey, then watched him sit out entirely as the No. 3 Huskies fell 85-79 to the No. 12 Wildcats on Wednesday at McKale Center, Yahoo Sports reported.
Dan Hurley did not hide his frustration afterward — about the loss, and much more about the legal chaos that decided who could even take the floor.
The Huskies arrived in Tucson with a 4-0 record and a game plan built around a two-big lineup that included Godfrey, who has yet to debut for Arizona this season. Instead, they trailed by 18 points at halftime, cut the deficit to eight at 62-54 in the second half, and ran out of time as the Wildcats improved to 4-1.
“I was literally asking on the bus ride over if Godfrey was eligible. Literally, you pull up to the arena, and you don’t know if he’s playing or not,” Hurley said in a postgame video posted by The Field of 68.
The 23-year-old transferred from Clemson for a fifth year, citing the NCAA’s new “five-for-five” eligibility model. A temporary restraining order granted Nov. 17 declared him eligible — but the NCAA refused to certify it, arguing Godfrey remained a party in another case, as ClutchPoints reported.

A court said yes, the NCAA said no
The Pima County Superior Court issued the restraining order and preliminary injunction the day before the game. The NCAA’s response: the new rule does not apply retroactively to players who already completed four seasons before it took effect. So Godfrey watched from the sideline while both sides claimed the law was on their side.
Hurley said the uncertainty shaped his preparation even though he refused to blame it for the result.
“Because of what we saw on social (media), we expected more of a two-big lineup. He was a big part of the scout. That had nothing to do with how this game went for us. But that shouldn’t be going on,” Hurley said.
Dan Hurley on the RJ Godfrey situation: “He was a big part of the scout. That had nothing to do with how this game went. But that shouldn’t be going on. I was literally asking on the bus ride over if he was eligible. You pull up to the arena and you don’t know if he’s playing or…”
Hurley points the finger at coaches, not just the NCAA
Speaking to reporters after the game, Hurley widened his critique well beyond one player, USA Today reported. He described the sport-wide eligibility mess as “really gross” and “unfortunate,” and blamed fellow coaches who chased ineligible players through the courts while his program stayed out.
“As an institution and as a program, we chose to follow the rules and the guidelines of the NCAA when they said the five-for-five rule starts next year. We ignored the calls from lawyers and agents telling us ‘Hey, these guys will get eligible.’ It’s unfortunate. It’s really gross.”
The NCAA passed the age-based model in June, giving athletes up to five years to compete — but made no provision for players from the high school class of 2022 who had already finished four seasons, USA Today reported. That gap has produced a wave of lawsuits and temporary restraining orders across the country, some involving players who had signed professional contracts.
One of them finally played Wednesday. RJ Luis, the former St. John’s player of the year who signed NBA and G League deals before returning to college at LSU, scored 11 points with nine rebounds in his Tigers debut — the same night Godfrey remained stuck in legal limbo.
Hurley argued the situation creates an unlevel playing field that no visiting coach can plan around.
“Programs that aren’t following the rules, when they come play a game in Connecticut and we followed the rules, should those players be allowed to play when they come into the state of Connecticut? Is there a judge in Connecticut that’s not going to allow players that are ineligible to come when they play us? Who the hell knows?”
Duke next, with no answers in sight
The loss dropped UConn to 4-1 and left Hurley little time to dwell on it. The Huskies face Duke on Wednesday in their marquee matchup.
Hurley, born in 1973 in Jersey City, New Jersey, has built a résumé few active coaches can match. Before arriving at UConn in 2018, he spent nine years building Saint Benedict’s Prep into one of the nation’s top high school programs, then revived Wagner and Rhode Island, taking the Rams to their first NCAA tournaments since 1999.
At UConn he won back-to-back national championships in 2023 and 2024, guided the Huskies to a school-record 37 wins, and was named Naismith College Coach of the Year.
His standing in the sport was underscored in 2024, when he declined head coaching offers from both Kentucky and the Los Angeles Lakers, choosing instead to stay in Storrs and pursue a third straight title.
Godfrey, meanwhile, still has not appeared in a game for Arizona.