David Booth Argues Investors Must Embrace Uncertainty, Not Beat It

In a new interview published this month, Dimensional Fund Advisors co-founder David Booth argues that investors can know far less than they think — and that accepting that uncertainty, not beating it, is the real skill.

The conversation, which ran on Institutional Investor’s podcast and site, centers on Booth’s book “Stay Calm: Learn to Embrace Uncertainty in Investing and Life,” published earlier this year.

Booth, who co-founded Dimensional after leaving the University of Chicago Graduate School of Business, told Institutional Investor that a century of public-market data shows most professional managers fail to beat the market — and that ordinary investors should stop assuming Wall Street holds an advantage.

“Many people, like my parents, view themselves as outsiders,” Booth said. “And they view that insiders make all the money, like Wall Street firms. And it turns out that’s really not true. Professional money managers don’t do better than market.”

That claim is the spine of the book, and of the interview. Booth traces it back to the research he encountered at Chicago, where professors Eugene Fama — Fama’s longtime research partner Ken French teaches at Dartmouth’s Tuck School of Business — along with Merton Miller and Myron Scholes were building the work on market efficiency that underpins modern finance.

Booth left the school to join Wells Fargo and then co-founded Dimensional, a firm built specifically to turn that academic research into investable products.

Video: Institutional Investor

Uncertainty as the Protagonist

What makes the book unusual, Booth told the outlet, is that uncertainty — not strategy — is its central character. He has spent his career studying markets, and his conclusion is that study has limits. You can research and research, he argues, but eventually you have to get comfortable with what you don’t know, in investing and in life.

He resists the label of optimist. When the interviewer called him one, he corrected her: he is a realist. The distinction, he explained, comes from having studied 100 years of data on public markets. When something alarms him, he can simply call the trading desk and ask whether trades are going through and settling — a detail he clearly relished.

Booth returned repeatedly, in the conversation, to the quality of data in public markets. Better data, he argues, made possible some of the most important discoveries in investing — including one he says deserved a “ticker tape parade”: the finding that individuals could buy an inexpensive market portfolio and do as well as the professionals.

The Private Markets Caveat

The sharpest part of the interview may be what Booth says about private markets, a topic he concedes is especially relevant now. The evidence on risk and return there, he acknowledges, is thinner — there simply is not the same depth of data.

He describes himself as open to private investments but wants investors to think hard about what they are getting in return for giving up liquidity, transparency, and confidence based on comprehensive data.

“There are any number of ways you can invest, but only in public markets do we have a lot of data that can really tell you about, you know, risk and return,” Booth told Institutional Investor.

That trade-off — liquidity and transparency exchanged for access — is the question the book poses to readers who are being courted by a private-markets industry expanding rapidly into retail channels. Booth does not answer it for them. He frames it as a question of what you can and cannot know.

Plain English Over Greek

Booth writes, he says, in English rather than the “Greek” jargon that can turn off his target audience — the same people, like his parents, who see themselves as outsiders to Wall Street. The book covers familiar ground in a new way, and the “Life” half of the title matters to him.

An earlier profile of Booth by the same author, published in 2016 under the headline “How David Booth Brings Academic Research to Life,” said that the word “Life” grabbed her: Booth needed to be in the world, making things.

That thread runs through the interview as well. Booth is a natural storyteller, and the conversation touches on how Jack Bogle helped him get Dimensional up and running, and on what his grandparents taught him about what money is for.

Where the Argument Lands

The practical upshot, as Booth presents it, is modest but demanding. Investors cannot eliminate uncertainty; they can only choose the arena where the evidence is strongest. Public markets, with their deep and well-documented records of risk and return, are that arena. Private markets may belong in a portfolio, but investors should enter them clear-eyed about what they are giving up.

The full conversation with Booth is available on YouTube, and as a podcast on Spotify, Apple, or other platforms. “Stay Calm: Embracing Uncertainty in Investing and Life” is on sale now.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Dietitians Name 2 Best Fruits for Managing High Blood Sugar