Voters in 10 states that supported Republican Donald Trump in the 2024 presidential election elected Democratic senators this year, creating a mismatch rate of 28.6% that marks a 20-year high for split outcomes between state presidential and Senate choices, according to a Pew Research Center analysis.
A Senate-presidential mismatch occurs when the party winning a Senate race differs from the party that won the state’s most recent presidential vote. Out of the 35 Senate seats on the ballot this cycle, 10 went to Democrats despite Trump carrying those same states in 2024, Jurelist reported in its coverage of the figures compiled by the Pew Research Center.
This 28.6% mismatch rate is the highest since 2006, when 10 of the 33 Senate seats up for election—or 30.3%—resulted in splits. No states bucked the trend in the opposite direction this year by electing a Republican senator after voting for Democrat Kamala Harris in the previous presidential election.
Historical Shifts in Senate Splits
While split outcomes feel notable today, they were once a standard feature of American politics. Back in the 1980s, when the Pew Research Center analysis begins, the mismatch rate consistently approached or exceeded 50%. Democrats regularly captured Senate seats in states that Republican Ronald Reagan carried during his two landslide presidential victories.
Those dynamics shifted by the mid-1990s. The mismatch rate has never exceeded 40% since that decade, frequently dropping much lower during cycles of heightened national polarization. In 2016, every single state’s Senate race aligned with its presidential pick, resulting in a 0% mismatch rate. Only one mismatch occurred in both the 2020-21 and 2022 election cycles.
Candidates from the party that won their state’s most recent presidential race have claimed 185 of 209 Senate contests, or 88.5%, since 2016. Independent senators who caucus with a major party are counted with that party for analytical purposes, including Bernie Sanders of Vermont, Angus King of Maine, and former Joseph Lieberman of Connecticut.
Former Senator Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona was similarly counted as a Democrat because she retained her committee assignments through the Democratic caucus after registering as an independent in December 2022.
Midterm Wave Elections Drive Recent Split Outcomes
Recent upticks in split outcomes typically coincide with wave elections. These are often midterm cycles where the party that lost the White House two years earlier rebounds strongly in Congress.
Before this year, the last time the mismatch rate topped 20% was during the 2017-18 election cycle. That period recorded eight mismatches out of 36 regular and special Senate elections, yielding a rate of 22.2% entirely driven by Democratic victories in states Trump had carried.

Historical data compiled from the U.S. House Clerk’s office and the Federal Election Commission records similar mid-term corrections:
Founded in 1990 as the Times Mirror Center for the People & the Press, the Pew Research Center became its current entity in 2004 after the Pew Charitable Trusts established it in Washington, D.C. The nonpartisan think tank, a subsidiary of the Trusts, conducts public opinion polling and demographic research without taking policy positions.
| Midterm Year | Total Mismatches | Primary Direction |
|---|---|---|
| 2006 | 10 | 9 Democratic wins, 1 Republican |
| 2010 | 10 | 10 Republican wins |
| 2017–18 | 8 | 8 Democratic wins |
| 2026 | 10 | 10 Democratic wins |
The Pew Research Center utilized election information from the Federal Election Commission and the U.S. House Clerk’s office for data spanning 1980 through 2022, while incorporating results from The New York Times election tracker for the 2024 and 2026 cycles.
Related reading
- Design Experts Share Small-Space Hosting Tips for Holiday Gatherings
- Atmospheric River Breaks Decades-Old Rain Records Across Southern California
- CDC: U.S. Measles Cases Hit 5,412, Highest in 35 Years (archyworldys.com)
- Morehouse Reviews Policy After Arrest; Ga. Lawmakers Seek Foster Audit; Senate OKs Energy Bill (archynewsy.com)