Pennsylvania’s State Board of Education meets Wednesday in Harrisburg to vote on a proposal that would let students score “advanced” on state tests with fewer points than it takes today.
Democrats for Education Reform is urging the board to reject it.
Under the Pennsylvania Department of Education’s plan, the minimum score needed to earn an advanced rating on PSSA math and reading would drop in nearly every grade, DFER reported. A student sitting just below today’s cutoff could be rated advanced without earning a single additional point. Department officials told the board the change would increase the number of students in that category.
The proficiency cutoff would stay put at 1,000. But the department’s own presentation says the shift would also touch the share of students rated below basic — and it would scramble comparisons with prior years, leaving families and educators without a clear read on whether achievement is actually rising or falling.
“We need to raise the bar and raise expectations, not lower them,” said Jorge Elorza, CEO of DFER. “Lowering the cutoff score so more students are rated advanced is like widening the goalposts. The same field goal that went wide right yesterday is counted as three points today.”
Elorza kept going. “Calling more students advanced does not mean more students have mastered advanced work, and families deserve labels that mean what they say,” he said. His organization wants the board to reject the proposal, release this year’s results on the existing scale, and revisit cut scores only once Pennsylvania adopts the new math and reading standards the department itself says are coming.
The last reset took new standards
There’s a precedent here, and it cuts against the department. Pennsylvania last reset its math and reading cut scores in 2015, and it did so to align its tests with the more rigorous PA Core Standards. New standards came first; the bar moved to match them.
This time, the sequence is reversed. Department officials argue the 2015 thresholds are overdue for an update — even as they estimate that new math and reading standards remain years away. The proposal would cover both the PSSA and the high school Keystone exams students took this spring.
The board approved a science cut score change in September, but only after that subject’s standards had been overhauled. The math and reading proposal before it Wednesday asks for the change before any such overhaul exists.
Philadelphia families are waiting
The review has already cost families real time. State officials have acknowledged that the cut score review contributed to a months-long delay in releasing Philadelphia’s scores, which families typically receive in August.
The timing is worse than it sounds. Applications to the city’s selective high schools are due Dec. 16, and families still don’t know whether their children qualify for some admissions lotteries. A label change in Harrisburg has become a paperwork problem in Philadelphia kitchens.
What happens Wednesday
The State Board of Education is expected to take up the proposal at its Nov. 19 meeting. If it approves the change, the department plans to share final school-level results with districts within days.
Statewide results would follow in early 2027, according to Education Secretary Carrie Rowe. By then, a student’s “advanced” rating would sit on a different scale from every year that came before it — which is precisely the comparison DFER says Pennsylvania can’t afford to lose.
Democrats for Education Reform was formed in 2007 as a New York-based political action committee and advocacy group that pushes the Democratic Party to back public education reform and charter schools. In its first few years it invested $17 million in political and policy advocacy, and it prepared a transition memo for the incoming Obama administration that helped place reformers like Arne Duncan, who became Secretary of Education, in key roles.
Since 2023 the organization has been led by Jorge Elorza, a former mayor of Providence, Rhode Island, and it now works with more than 180 Democratic officeholders at the federal, state and local levels.
Whatever the board decides, the labels on this spring’s tests will either mean what they meant in 2024 — or something easier to earn.