Dogs Top Cats in Live Science Poll on Which Animal Readers Want to Talk

“I would want to know my horse’s backstory.” That comment, from one reader of Live Science, sits at the heart of a reader poll published by the outlet on Thursday, November 19, in which more than 550 people voted on which animal they would most want to talk to — and dogs won decisively, taking 54% of the vote.

The poll was prompted by new research from Julie Elie, an ethologist at the University of California, Berkeley, who used artificial intelligence and behavioral experiments to decode the different vocalizations of zebra finches (Taeniopygia guttata).

Live Science described the work as bringing scientists one step closer to talking to animals — a deliberately careful phrase, as streakshot.com’s analysis of the poll points out: the research distinguishes and links different calls to situations, but it is not a finished translator.

Cats came second at 28%, meaning dogs and cats together accounted for 82% of all votes cast, according to figures reported by Live Science and corroborated by urgent.news and streakshot.com. The gap between the two — 26 percentage points, with dogs drawing nearly twice the feline vote — is large for a poll of this size, streakshot.com noted.

'I would want to know my horse's backstory': Live Science readers share which animals they'd want to speak with
Photo: urgent.news

Why readers chose the animals on their couches

The comments, Live Science reported, reflected an obvious trend: people wanted to speak to their own pets, not to wildlife. One reader explained the choice plainly:

“Cats, simply because I’ve had more of them as pets over the decades than anything else. I don’t think spiders would be interesting conversationalists, I’m unlikely to encounter whales here in the middle of North America, and dogs that I meet on my daily walks are only invested in the canine treats I carry.”

Not everyone stayed within the poll’s options. Several commenters nominated octopuses, absent from the list. “I’m disappointed that octopi weren’t included on the list,” one wrote, citing reports that they are “incredibly intelligent, interact with humans and are able to think and plan,” and can “shape shift and change color and patterns.”

Readers overwhelmingly choose dogs and cats to talk to

  • When given the chance to talk to any animal on Earth, most people chose the one already living with them — 82% picked dogs or cats.
  • The poll followed real science: an AI-assisted study decoding zebra finch calls at UC Berkeley, plus ongoing work on sperm whale and humpback whale clicks and calls.
  • A reader poll on a science website is not a scientific survey of the public — streakshot.com flags that respondents likely already follow animal news and often own pets.

The skeptic’s objection: you would have to ‘be’ a dog

The most philosophically pointed comment, quoted by Live Science, argued that translation alone would never close the gap between species:

Animals humans want to talk to
Photo: streakshot.com

“Unfortunately you would have to experience the world through your nose to truly understand what they experience. To understand what a dog is thinking you would have to ‘be’ a dog. A problem with communicating with any non-human being, whether it be octopi, whale, cat or extra terrestrial. It seems to be a human thing that people can’t just sit, observe and interpret the world around them as it is. Everything needs to be explained!”

Even the familiar house cat adjusts its vocal output to its audience: Live Science said that cats can change their meows depending on what they are seeking from owners, such as food or attention. Decoding the signal is one problem; sharing the sensory world that produced it is another.

What Elie’s zebra finch work does — and does not — mean

The Berkeley study sits inside a much wider research effort. Scientists are also working to decipher the clicks of sperm whales and the calls of humpback whales, sound systems widely regarded as among the most complex in the animal kingdom, as streakshot.com’s reporting on the poll notes.

Zebra finches are a common laboratory species precisely because their calls and songs are highly structured, which makes them tractable for AI-assisted classification paired with controlled behavioral experiments.

What Elie’s team achieved, per Live Science’s framing, is a way to tell different calls apart and connect them to specific situations or behaviors. That is a meaningful step toward understanding animal communication; it is not a conversation.

Reader choice (Live Science poll, Nov. 19, 2026) Share of vote
Dog 54%
Cat 28%
Dogs and cats combined 82%
Total respondents Over 550

Outlets report same poll numbers but differ in emphasis

All four outlets covering the poll — Live Science, urgent.news, eng.pressbee.net and streakshot.com — report the same core figures: more than 550 voters, 54% for dogs, 28% for cats. They diverge in emphasis. urgent.news and eng.pressbee.net are close condensations of Live Science’s report, with PressBee noting its version was edited and verified and may have been modified from the original. streakshot.com adds the only genuinely new analysis: the 82% combined share, the 26-point margin, and the caveat that this was a self-selected reader poll rather than a representative survey.

It also draws out the meaning of the horse comment — that many animals arrive through adoption, rescue or a previous owner, and their early life often stays a mystery no matter how well an owner reads their body language.

When Animal Behavior Warrants Professional Attention

None of the sources offers medical or veterinary guidance, and none should be read as doing so. What the poll does show, implicitly, is that owners already interpret animal signals constantly — a cat's meow pitched for food versus attention, a dog's investment in a passing walker's treat pouch.

Sudden or marked changes in a pet’s vocalization or behavior are the kind of signal owners cannot decode from a poll, a study or a comment thread; those are questions for a veterinarian, who can assess the animal directly. The reader who said you would have to “’be’ a dog” to know what one is thinking was, in effect, making the same case for professional observation over armchair translation.

What happens next in animal communication research

The zebra finch findings land amid parallel efforts on whales, whose clicks and calls researchers are still working to decipher, and on species whose social cognition keeps surprising scientists — related reporting linked by Live Science includes findings that elephants greet friends with ear flaps and rumbles, that octopuses are surprisingly social and confrontational, and that male lemurs “stink flirt” using fruity, floral scent signals.

Live Science closed its poll by asking readers whether they agree or disagree with the choices — and the comment section, as of Thursday, was doing exactly what polls like this tend to do: turning a bird-song study into a conversation about the animals waiting at home.

Elie, who describes herself as a computational neuroethologist, is the first author of the paper on the findings, published in the Sept. 18 issue of the journal Science. As a graduate student in the ENES lab in France, she spent time in Australia trailing pairs and flocks of zebra finches, and in 2010 showed, by placing microphones in their nests, that the birds sing private quiet duets.

After joining the Berkeley lab 15 years ago, she recreated those conditions in captivity and cataloged 11 distinct vocalizations, matching the calls documented by the late ornithologist Richard Zann in a 1996 book — though Elie, unlike Zann, also analyzed their acoustics.

References

  • Live Science — ‘I would want to know my horse’s backstory’: Live Science readers share which animals they’d want to speak with (November 19, 2026)
  • urgent.news — syndicated coverage of the Live Science reader poll (November 19, 2026)
  • streakshot.com — Animals Humans Want to Talk to: Dogs Beat Cats in Live Science Poll (November 19, 2026)
  • eng.pressbee.net — edited and verified republication of the Live Science report (November 20, 2026)

Disclaimer: This article reports on a reader poll and published science coverage. It is not veterinary or medical advice; consult a qualified veterinarian or physician for guidance on animal behavior or health concerns.

Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

Saudi Arabia Intercepts Houthi Ballistic Missile Near Jizan Border