Donald Van der Vaart, one of five members of the North Carolina Utilities Commission, will resign effective Jan. 1, according to a Wednesday announcement from State Treasurer Brad Briner, who appointed him.
The timing stands out. The resignation comes just days after Van der Vaart sat out a major commission decision that allows Duke Energy to raise residential customers’ bills by more than 9% over the next two years, and after his colleagues barred him from voting on a second key Duke case.
Briner, a Republican, confirmed he had accepted the resignation in a press release. “I appreciate Don’s willingness to serve on the Utilities Commission and wish him the best,” Briner said.
Neither the treasurer’s announcement nor the commission offered a reason for the departure. WRAL reports that Van der Vaart is leaving four and a half years before his term was scheduled to expire, and that the announcement gave no explanation for why.
He sat out the Duke Energy rate case
The rate decision Van der Vaart skipped is among the commission’s most consequential of the year. Duke Energy, which provides electricity to most of North Carolina, won approval for residential rate increases of roughly 9% over two years, along with new financial requirements aimed at large energy users such as data centers.
Not voting on a decision that large is highly uncommon, and the commission did not explain why Van der Vaart did not participate. He did, however, issue a partial dissent, writing that he agreed with most of the order but that it “does not reflect the risk this Order shifts from Duke to its customers.”
The other four commissioners — Republicans William Brawley and Tommy Tucker and Democrats Floyd McKissick and John Gajda — all voted to approve the increase. McKissick and Gajda issued concurring opinions. Van der Vaart was the only one to dissent, arguing in his partial dissent for a lower return on equity for the utility than the 9.8% the commission approved, according to WRAL’s report on the case.
Separately, Van der Vaart was barred by his colleagues from voting this week on Duke’s biennial Carbon Plan because he had missed more than two weeks of hearings in the case — which WRAL attributes to him missing evidentiary hearings while on vacation.
The data center dispute behind his dissent
At the center of Van der Vaart’s dissent was a set of rules passed as part of the rate increase governing who pays when data centers break their contracts early. He argued the rules could leave everyday customers covering nearly half of data centers’ electric costs in that scenario.
As an example, the commission calculated that a hypothetical 500-megawatt data center could require Duke to build about $674 million in new electric infrastructure. If that customer left after 15 years, Van der Vaart wrote, it would pay only $338 million of those costs — leaving the other $335 million to everyday customers.
“In the end, it falls to this Commission to be the counterweight — to ensure that the utility’s legitimate duty to its shareholders, and the data centers’ legitimate interest in lower costs, do not become an obligation of the families, small businesses and manufacturers who remain on the system,” Van der Vaart wrote in his dissent.
A divisive figure in environmental regulation
Van der Vaart, a chemical engineer and lawyer, spent more than 20 years as a scientist in the state Department of Environmental Quality’s Division of Air Quality. He served as DEQ secretary under former Gov. Pat McCrory until 2016 — and when former Gov. Roy Cooper took office, he “demoted” himself to a mid-level department job to avoid being removed as a political appointee.
His tenure at DEQ ended amid controversy. In 2017, shortly after co-authoring an opinion piece calling for the elimination of a key federal air quality rule, he was placed on administrative leave.
“This leave is being initiated in order to investigate concerns regarding your conduct and recent actions that may have compromised the Division of Air Quality and the Department of Environmental Quality,” a letter from the department’s human resources director read at the time. He later resigned from DEQ.
During President Donald Trump’s first term, Van der Vaart was shortlisted for several posts at the federal EPA and was appointed to the EPA’s Science Advisory Board. A longtime critic of EPA regulation, he has publicly questioned the extent of human contributions to climate change.
“I certainly think mankind contributes” to climate change, he said in a 2018 interview with E&E News. “How and how much is something I’d like to have more answers on and more accuracy.”
What the vacancy changes on the commission
The Utilities Commission oversees major utility decisions in North Carolina, and its five seats are split among appointing authorities: two members named by the governor, one by the state treasurer and two by the legislature. With Van der Vaart’s exit, the panel currently consists of three Republicans — Van der Vaart, William Brawley and Tommy Tucker — and two Democrats, Floyd McKissick and John Gajda, until a replacement is seated.
According to WRAL, the opening arrives just weeks before Democrats are set to take control of the state House, and after Republican lawmakers previously restructured the commission — shrinking it from seven members to five and shifting appointment power away from the governor.
The Charlotte Observer reported that the resignation lands amid one of the commission’s busiest stretches, with Duke’s newly approved rate increases taking effect the same day Van der Vaart leaves.
Briner said he will announce an appointment to fill the vacancy in the coming weeks — WRAL reports he put it at days or weeks — leaving one of the state’s most powerful regulatory seats open as the Duke orders take effect Jan. 1.