Medicare’s annual open enrollment asks older Americans to pick from thousands of plans whose complexity a 2025 eHealth survey found confusing for 75 percent of beneficiaries — and a physician who spent 25 years working as a medical director and medical executive for several health insurance companies says the system itself appears engineered to produce poor decisions.
That physician is Dr. Edward Anselm. His copy of the federal handbook Medicare & You, covering New York City and surrounding counties, runs 131 pages. It lists 71 Medicare Advantage choices, 12 Medigap plan designs, 56 Special Needs Plans, and 9 Part D drug coverage options.
“If I find this handbook confusing, after 25 years working as a medical director and medical executive for several health insurance companies, how does the average consumer feel?” Anselm asks.
The stakes are financial as much as clinical. A Kaiser Family Foundation study found that 22 percent of Americans aged 65 and older report having medical or dental debt, and medical expenses contribute substantially to bankruptcy. A choice made during the current open enrollment period remains in effect for all of 2027.
Traditional Medicare is national; private plans operate state by state
- Traditional Medicare Parts A and B are national programs.
- Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Medicare Part D plans adhere to a federally defined benefit structure, yet each one is run by private health insurers working within regulated markets at the state level.
- In many states, once the initial protected enrollment window has passed, insurers may apply medical underwriting to refuse Medigap coverage or impose higher costs.
75 percent call the choice confusing
Beyond the 75 percent who found choosing a plan bewildering in the 2025 eHealth survey, 33 percent said they lacked a solid grasp of how Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D plans differ from one another.
An AARP survey found that close to half of Medicare Advantage beneficiaries were unsure whether returning to traditional Medicare was possible, and over half were unclear about their capacity to secure Medigap coverage at that point.
Psychologist Barry Schwartz described the mechanism in his book The Paradox of Choice: beyond a certain point, additional alternatives increase the difficulty of decision-making, amplify uncertainty, and leave people less satisfied with their decisions.
Thousands of plans, 28 on average per person
| Plan type | Total nationally | Average choices per beneficiary |
|---|---|---|
| Medicare Advantage | 5,335 | 28 |
| Part D drug coverage | 316 | 9 |
How the premiums are actually set
Each plan is the product of an actuarial calculation, Anselm explains: the average cost of medical services in a region during the previous year, expected medical utilization of the population, a medical cost inflation factor, and an additional percentage for overhead and profit.
Premiums, deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance are filed with federal or state governments for approval, a process designed to verify the insurer can pay the benefits the policy outlines.
By law, health insurance companies must devote 85 percent of the premium dollars they collect to genuine medical costs like physician fees, prescription drugs, and hospital stays. The remaining 15 percent may be kept for their administrative costs and profit. For comparison, traditional Medicare spends 2 percent on administration.
The single-payer alternative
Anselm presents a single-payer model as a structural alternative: Physicians for a National Health Plan has spent decades promoting a single-payer approach, and most of the public now favors shifting that way.
The core idea is to remove the middleman and free up the dollars spent on administration and profit by health insurers so they can pay for stronger benefits for every consumer and improved reimbursement for the majority of physicians.
The current framework assumes consumers know how much health insurance they need, how much they can afford, and can make appropriate selections, yet insurance exists to protect against the unexpected — and serious illnesses can occur suddenly with catastrophic economic consequences. Some people who worry about additional expenses may delay care this year while waiting to purchase better coverage next year.
Verify networks and drug costs before switching plans
Beneficiaries managing chronic conditions requiring specialist care, home health, or Part B drugs should verify network participation and drug costs before switching, since the handbook’s own guidance directs consumers to go online to discover if their doctors are “in-network” and how much their medications might cost.
Anyone with a serious new diagnosis who enrolled in Medicare Advantage should consult a counselor promptly about Medigap eligibility in their state, because medical underwriting rules vary and the protected window may already have closed.
A decision that outlasts the year
Medicare open enrollment ends December 7, and the plan selected will govern coverage through all of 2027. Official plan comparison is available at Medicare.gov’s Find the plan that works for you tool. Anselm’s verdict on the system he helped run: the complexity “seems to be engineered to produce poor decisions.”
References
- Edward Anselm, MD, “Medicare choices at open enrollment: Is there a better way?” kevinmd.com
- Kaiser Family Foundation, study on medical and dental debt among Americans aged 65 and older
- 2025 eHealth survey on Medicare plan selection
- AARP survey on Medicare Advantage beneficiary awareness
- Barry Schwartz, The Paradox of Choice