Dutch football law allows hooligans to be punished ten times harder than in England, according to a Groningen law professor who says the widespread comparison with the English “Hooligan Act” is a myth — even after fireworks halted two Dutch matches in the past month.
Jan Brouwer, professor of Law and Society at the University of Groningen, has spent thirty years studying football vandalism, NOS reported. Speaking Sunday on the radio program Langs de Lijn En Omstreken, he dismantled the idea that England has the problem better under control.
“Netherlands has the strictest football law in the world, much stricter than England,” Brouwer said on the program.
The timing is pointed. Last month the Eredivisie match between Cambuur and Go Ahead Eagles was definitively abandoned after fireworks were set off twice in the away section. Two weeks ago, the second-division fixture Vitesse–De Graafschap could not be played because De Graafschap supporters were barred from Arnhem — and blocked their own team’s bus in anger.
Ten times harsher
Brouwer told NOS the Dutch law is “an accumulation of all kinds of legal provisions on the basis of which we can punish hooligans in an extremely crafty way, which are ten times what is possible in England.”
The key lies in a legal swap made in England in the late 1980s, when criminal law was replaced by civil law. Stadium bans there are imposed by a civil court, where the burden of proof is far lower than in criminal proceedings.
The Netherlands copied that model — and then went further. Dutch authorities also created the power to impose fines, something that is impossible in England, Brouwer said. And the Netherlands is, he argued, the only country in the world where a supporter with a stadium ban also faces a reporting obligation.
In England, that obligation only applies when matches are played on the European mainland: the banned supporter must surrender his passport and cannot leave the island. For matches in England itself, there is no reporting duty at all.
The silent press agreement
So why does England look better run? Brouwer had a blunt answer. “There is in England, but also in other countries, a silent agreement with the press that not too much is reported about it,” he said. Keep hooliganism to small news items, so supporters do not enjoy their finest hour after setting a train carriage on fire.
“The strictest punishments stand for murder and manslaughter, but that does not prevent it. The same applies to football vandalism,” Brouwer said. “Emotions come into play there, and whatever punishment you give for it, it happens. People simply cannot control themselves.”
The hooligan population also keeps renewing itself, he noted. After the corona crisis, older supporters withdrew and young newcomers had to prove themselves. In some supporter groups, causing mayhem is a badge of honour.
Where England genuinely wins
Brouwer does see one area where England holds a real edge, and it is not the law. Since 1994, England has had a dedicated football policing unit of roughly one hundred officers who track hooligans around the clock. When Brouwer has floated the idea with the Dutch police, the answer has been the same: the willingness is there, the capacity is not.
“You would have to free up money for that politically, as has been done in England,” he said.
The same money question applies at the turnstiles. Dutch stewards are, according to Brouwer, often well-meaning volunteers with minimal or no training, while England deploys well-trained staff with equipment to summon multiple people at once.
Communication is his third improvement point. The chance that the same supporter reoffends is small, he argued, and he has pleaded for years for the KNVB to communicate far better on how a supporter can be caught and how heavy the sanctions are — including the public prosecutor coming to your door.
What it means for the clubs
De Graafschap’s bus blockade and the abandonment of the Cambuur match pushed stadium security and fan conduct back onto club agendas at a cost-sensitive moment in the Dutch football calendar.
| Recent Dutch match stoppages | Competition | Cause |
|---|---|---|
| Cambuur – Go Ahead Eagles (abandoned, last month) | Eredivisie | Fireworks set off twice in away section |
| Vitesse – De Graafschap (not played, two weeks ago) | Eerste Divisie | De Graafschap fans barred; players’ bus blocked |
| sc Heerenveen – NEC (delayed, late October) | Eredivisie | Fireworks in away section |
Here is what the analytics missed, if you only counted stadium bans: Netherlands already outclasses England on paper. The next move, per Brouwer, is not another law but money — a dedicated football police unit, trained stewards, and clearer communication about how heavy the hammer already is.
The University of Groningen, where Brouwer holds his chair, was founded in 1614 and is the second oldest university in the Netherlands, after Leiden. Law was one of its four original faculties, alongside Theology, Medicine and Philosophy, and today the institution counts more than 30,000 students.
Its alumni include Aletta Jacobs, the country’s first female physician and a pioneer of women’s rights, as well as four Nobel Prize winners and the first president of the European Central Bank.
“Men kan zich gewoon niet beheersen,” as Brouwer put it on the program: people simply cannot control themselves. Until capacity follows legislation, the strictest football law in the world will keep getting tested at the turnstiles.