Eleven Japan-US Environmental Groups Oppose Up to $40 Billion Financing for 10 US SMR Projects

Eleven Japanese and American environmental groups went public on Nov. 19 with their opposition to Japanese financing for 10 small nuclear reactor projects in the United States, a package worth as much as $40 billion, Dellows News(デロウズニュース) reported.

The joint statement targets two Japanese lenders: the Japan Bank for International Cooperation (JBIC) and Nippon Export and Investment Insurance (NEXI). Both are weighing support for the projects, and both are wholly owned by the Japanese government — meaning any loss lands, in the groups’ words, squarely on Japanese taxpayers.

JBIC and NEXI placed the 10 projects on their lists of projects under consideration for support on Oct. 23, which starts a clock: once listed, a funding decision can come as soon as 45 days after disclosure.

The projects in question are five units at the Clinch River nuclear plant in Tennessee and five at the Bellefonte plant in Alabama, all slated to run GE Vernova Hitachi’s BWRX-300 small modular reactor. The groups argue the economics do not hold up.

A $550 billion package under strain

The statement argues the legal floor beneath that deal has already given way.

Cost is the other pillar of their case. Small modular reactors tend to cost more per unit of electricity generated than large conventional reactors, the statement says, which casts doubt on whether Japanese loans would ever be repaid. It cites one cautionary precedent: NuScale Power’s American SMR project, killed off in November 2023 when construction costs spiraled.

One environmental review out of ten

Disclosure is where the groups say the two Japanese agencies are falling short of their own rules. Of the 10 projects, environmental impact statements appear on JBIC’s and NEXI’s websites for only one — Clinch River Unit 1.

That, the statement argues, breaches the agencies’ own information disclosure guidelines for nuclear projects, which make publication of siting and construction plans, waste management plans and environmental reviews the default. The groups also reject the agencies’ treatment of environmental review as exceptional under their environmental guidelines, saying this round of projects meets none of the criteria for an exemption.

The environmental objections go into detail. Drawing on the published Clinch River Unit 1 review, the groups flag heavy water intake and discharge that would raise river temperatures, harm to aquatic ecosystems and threatened species, and cumulative strain on a region already dense with nuclear facilities — with risks falling hardest on nearby residents and on minority and low-income communities.

Three further concerns round out the statement: calls to sharply shrink emergency planning zones would weaken protection for people living nearby; the United States still has no final repository for high-level radioactive waste; and the agencies never compared the projects against alternatives such as solar power and battery storage.

Racing a 45-day clock

What happens next is largely a matter of the calendar the listing itself created. With the Oct. 23 listing in place, JBIC and NEXI can decide on financing for any of the 10 projects once 45 days have passed since disclosure, according to Dellows News(デロウズニュース).

Nippon Export and Investment Insurance, known as NEXI, is Japan’s official export credit agency, wholly owned by the government and operating under the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry. The trade and investment insurance system it now runs dates to a law enacted in March 1950 and was administered directly by the government for about fifty years before NEXI was created as an incorporated administrative agency on April 1, 2001.

On April 1, 2017, it was reorganized into a stock company wholly owned by the state, with the government undertaking to support its ability to pay claims in an emergency. Its cover protects Japanese exporters, investors and lending banks against political risks such as war and foreign-exchange restrictions, as well as commercial risks like counterparty default.

Their concrete demand is that the entire investment-and-financing framework with the United States be returned to a blank slate and renegotiated, on the argument that government-owned lenders carrying risk at this scale converts, in the end, into a bill for Japanese taxpayers.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Houston Texans vs Indianapolis Colts Week 11: How to Watch TNF on Prime Video and DAZN

Czech NIX.CZ Hits Record 4 Tbps Traffic During GTA 6 Preload