EU Commissioner McGrath Urges Founders to Give Start-up Regulation ‘a Chance

“Give the process a chance,” Commissioner Michael McGrath told the Irish Independent this week, urging founders and investors led by Stripe co-founder Patrick Collison to hold fire on demands to scrap the draft EU Inc. regulation.

The justice commissioner acknowledged the frustration. The Irish presidency’s compromise text, hammered out among governments, strips out the Commission’s proposed online bankruptcy regime, caps employee stock options and lets member states challenge where a start-up chooses to incorporate. “There are changes to the Commission proposal that they made which I would rather were not made,” McGrath said.

Andreas Klinger, a solo investor with Prototype Capital and the group’s figurehead, called the original proposal “really, really good” and said the current version is unusable. “Europe, as much as I love it, is a completely fragmented mess: 27 to 30-plus countries, different legal codes,” he said in a video posted on X. He met Commission President Ursula von der Leyen weeks ago to ask her to withdraw the draft.

The stakes are structural. The Commission’s March proposal aimed to let founders incorporate in any EU country within 48 hours and operate under a single rulebook across the bloc — a European analogue to Delaware’s General Corporation Law. Delaware hosts more than 1.9 million legal entities, according to the state’s Division of Corporations, and its Court of Chancery provides predictable, specialist resolution of corporate disputes. The EU has no equivalent.

Feature Commission Proposal (March) Irish Presidency Compromise
Incorporation timeline 48 hours, fully online Retained
Employee stock options Common EU framework Capped usage
Bankruptcy procedure Fast-track online regime Scrapped
Member-state challenge Not included Governments can contest incorporation choice

McGrath said he will “make the case” for the original text once three-way talks with the European Parliament begin. MEPs have not yet finalised their position. The Parliament’s rapporteur, Axel Voss, has previously warned that watering down the digital incorporation tool risks turning EU Inc. into a “paper tiger” that founders simply ignore.

The friction mirrors a broader pattern. The Capital Markets Union, first proposed in 2015, remains incomplete because national insolvency laws and supervisory cultures resist harmonisation. A 2023 European Central Bank study found that fragmented legal frameworks add an estimated 10–15 per cent to the cost of cross-border equity financing for early-stage firms.

Collison’s group handed their blueprint to McGrath last year. They argue the compromise reintroduces the very fragmentation the regulation was designed to erase. McGrath countered that political reality requires patience. “The reality of political negotiations is that, you know, the 27 member states will bring their own national issues to the table. You do end up with a compromise in the end,” he said.

McGrath took the justice portfolio in September 2024 after two years as Minister for Finance, where he set up the Future Ireland Fund and the Infrastructure, Climate and Nature Fund to shore up long‑term public finances.

Before that he ran the €165 billion National Development Plan as Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform. A chartered accountant by training, he entered politics on Passage West Town Council in 1999 and won his first Dáil seat for Cork South‑Central in 2007, holding it through Fianna Fáil’s 2011 collapse.

Next steps hinge on the Parliament’s vote, expected before the summer recess. If the three institutions cannot agree on a text that preserves the fast-track incorporation and a functional insolvency path, the regulation risks joining the long list of single-market initiatives that promised Delaware and delivered a directory of national carve-outs.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

I Was Exhausted’: Filmmaker Poppy Jay Spends Two Days as a Tradwife for BBC Documentary

Social Democrats Leader Holly Cairns Gives Birth to Baby Boy